Casey's in Montgomery City, MO, located at 600 S Sturgeon St, is known for its delicious pizza made with scratch dough and real mozzarella cheese. Customers can enjoy a variety of appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and groceries, along with quality fuel for their vehicles. The staff, including a helpful associate, has received praise for excellent customer service. Many love the cookies, although experiences can vary at different locations. While some stores may feel small and in need of updates, Casey's remains a convenient stop for snacks, pizza, coffee, and quick services like gas and restrooms. Overall, Casey's offers a reliable and enjoyable experience for those in the area.
Getting fuel here is my best experience. I dont prefer the inside as much, the environment has an off vibe, their kitchen SUX! And I wouldn't recommend this Casey's I'd recommend the New Florence Casey's or the Wellsville Casey's over this Montgomery City Casey's.
May 2026
They had the cheapest fuel price the day I stopped in
April 2026
Just not as clean or friendly as most Casey's Ive been to
