-
January 2024 by Robert McClain
I recommend Save a Lot if you're grocery shopping in New Haven.Seitter's has a reasonably adequate selection, slightly higher prices than I expected, and a mostly friendly staff... one problem.I entered the store with bags from another local business and put them in my cart. I was maybe 20 feet inside the store before I was approached and asked to leave my CART at the register... My response was "I intend to use my cart for shopping". I was asked to remove the bags and leave them at register 3. What I wanted to say was "Do I look like a thief? No, I don't." I would suggest a revision of your store policy, or perhaps criminal profiling courses for your employees.Personally, I won't be returning to this store. I do not appreciate being humiliated and treated like a thief.
-
December 2023 by Linda Cherry
Absolutely wonderful family community grocery.
-
December 2023 by Lauren Crockett
Lisa and her team with Front Street Catering out of Seitter's Market are amazing! We got so many compliments on our wedding food. Guest's said that it was the best wedding food they've had, and we agree! My husband and I want to make the trip just to get a plate at the market soon. 10/10 recommend.
-
October 2023 by Linda Kleinheider
Great Store !!!! Friendly Older Cashier ?
-
September 2023 by Abigail Shipley
We used Seitter's Market for our wedding catering as well as cake and everything was amazing. We received countless compliments on the food and the pricing was very affordable. Lisa and her team were wonderful to work with throughout the process and on the day of the event.
-
August 2023 by Jay
I stopped in on our way through town a few years ago- I live about 20 miles east of here. I first found that their pork steaks are cut and trimmed nicely, and have a much better flavor than pork I get elsewhere. Later I found this to be true of their beef also. But I recently bought a pack of chicken and both my wife and I couldn’t believe how much better their chicken tastes compared to the chicken we get elsewhere! I seasoned and grilled it the same as I always do, but the flavor was far superior! I don’t know if this is due to the smaller farmers that provide their meats- that’s the only thing I can think of. But I’m going to start driving the extra 15 or 20 miles to buy their meat because I am constantly amazed by how much better their meat tastes compared to what I get from larger grocers. And their house-made desserts are on par with high end bakeries, and I already drive there to buy birthday cakes, etc. I’ll be honest, some of their other groceries are priced higher than what I pay elsewhere. But overall this place is a true gem, and worthy of a 5 star rating!
-
August 2023 by Ryan traughber
A great family owned store in rural New Haven, nice compact quick friendlyNeat and clean actual check out lane and no do it yourself check outUser-friendly
-
July 2023 by Jay N
I stopped in on our way through town a few years ago- I live about 20 miles east of here. I first found that their pork steaks are cut and trimmed nicely, and have a much better flavor than pork I get elsewhere. Later I found this to be true of their beef also. But I recently bought a pack of chicken and both my wife and I couldn’t believe how much better their chicken tastes compared to the chicken we get elsewhere! I seasoned and grilled it the same as I always do, but the flavor was far superior! I don’t know if this is due to the smaller farmers that provide their meats- that’s the only thing I can think of. But I’m going to start driving the extra 15 or 20 miles to buy their meat because I am constantly amazed by how much better their meat tastes compared to what I get from larger grocers. And their house-made desserts are on par with high end bakeries, and I already drive there to buy birthday cakes, etc. I’ll be honest, some of their other groceries are priced higher than what I pay elsewhere. But overall this place is a true gem, and worthy of a 5 star rating!
-
May 2023 by Brandy Donner
Great owners and employees are all very friendly!
-
May 2023 by Tina Wilson
Very over priced for a small town!!
-
April 2023 by David L Kelley (Dave)
Awesome place. They always have hometown exclusives no one else has. Staff always friendly and helpful. Beautiful store. Got to go see them. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
-
January 2023 by Missy Evans
Friendly hometown grocery store!! The staff are so helpfu!!
-
November 2022 by T Jay
I used to like this place but there has been alot brown meat and some I bought and opened was clearly bad. I wouldn't recommend buying meat from here. I should have taken pics .
-
September 2022 by Erin Raedeke
Their catering and floral services are excellent.
-
September 2022 by Matt Pryor
Best grocery store ever!
