-
September 2025 by Jennifer Ohrmund
I ordered through the app and was updated that my pizza had been delivered. It was not delivered. I contacted the store and was told that they were unable to help me. That I needed to contact my delivery person. The delivery person would not answer. So basically I was screwed. Would not refund me or make me another pizza with out pay again! Worst customer service ever!
-
September 2025 by Haley Peal
Just like any other Casey’s except warning: don’t use air pressure pump for your tires. They charge you money for a pump that doesn’t work.
-
September 2025 by Tim Fields
Little big black girl with glasses behind the counter. This morning just stood there as customers, I waited. And then tried to get attitude with me when I asked her why she couldn't help us. Many people waiting. While your people stand around. 🤷♂️
-
July 2025 by Kai
Helpful people
-
September 2024 by Chris & Sarah Boyd
While going to this location today to get a fountain drink and slice of pizza I was VERY disturbed about what I saw. I was at the drink area and there is a counter in between the drinks and pizza/straw area. There was pizza dough in a white tub that appeared to be made and rising or something and said use by tomorrow on the sticker. As I looked in the tub, there were gnats and bugs landing on the dough and customers moving across to get their things. Needless to say, I no longer wanted a slice of pizza. I asked the cashier what was going on with the dough just sitting out like that. The only response I got was "I don't know, I'll have to ask them what they are doing". If that dough is legit being used, that is EXTREMELY concerning and if it was something being thrown out, that is not a good look or sanitary either around the other food and people.
-
October 2023 by Karen Rust
Never any receipt paper in the pumps no matter what time of the month you stop by what time of the day what hour. Excuse was the storm knocked the pump out well we haven't had any storms for over a month and a half. Very poor maintenance schedule.
-
September 2023 by Lauren Griffiths
Great service! They were super busy tonight and still went out of their way to take my walk-in order! Pizza was amazing and staff was very nice!
-
August 2023 by Mark Atwell
Pizza was late, burnt, tough, and uncut. Will not be ordering from this location again
-
February 2023 by ALRIGHTY THEN
Now we get to pay for air after buying gas? As awesome as that sounds, I'll just head to Quiktrip instead.
-
December 2022 by Boss Yoda
Came in to buy lunch and nothing was in the warmer. All of the employees were standing together in the back room and there was nothing in the food warmers. I asked if there was a way I could put in an order for something and was told it’s be a long wait because their having a meeting. Maybe the first thing you should go over in this meeting is the fact that you have a customer asking for a service
-
November 2022 by Todd Cross
Delivery has changed to door dash and the level of service is embarrassing. Pizza was picked up notifications made and finally cancelled. Then find out that I need to try and request refund through the Casey’s app.
-
July 2022 by Sarah Ngo
DoorDash messed up my pizza deliver. I ordered in the casts app so I’d course I got the you have to call the other routine. However, the staff and manager Dylan did everything to make it right. I hope corporate figures out how to deal with mistakes that DoorDash makes.
-
June 2022 by Honey Harrison
My husband and I don't ever want to get in a pizza rut. So to keep the spark alive we mostly move between Casey's and Minsky's... We absolutely love the MadisonStreet Casey's, and think it's the best of them out of the many in the area! Every order we have ever made with them has been prompt, consistent, and delicious. And most importantly they have always checked with us on pick up, if/when we had a special request before we leave... just to make sure they are met to our standards. They definitely always go above and beyond to make sure we are happy - and that pizza this week was the best I've had in a while! It was for sure more than perfectly well done! ...Thanks again!
-
December 2021 by Marie J.
Every Casey's I go to is so lazy and they refuse to make pepperoni pizza because I guarantee it sells faster then the other slices but I can always count on this Casey's to have what I need. I always get exceptional service as well. Out of all of raymore belton and peculiar this is the best Casey's by far. The reviews don't do it justice
-
July 2021 by Brandi Lewis
My whole order is on point! SO good!
