Casey's on N Commercial Ave in St Clair offers pizza delivery and pickup, featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. The location also provides appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, groceries, and household essentials, alongside quality fuels for gas. Reviews highlight a mix of experiences regarding both food and service. Many customers praise the pizza, calling it good, while others find it can be dry. Opinions on other menu items vary sharply; the cheesy breadsticks are noted as hot and delicious, but the hot wings are heavily criticized and called the worst, with a preference stated for the old style. Customer service experiences differ greatly depending on the staff and shift. Several reviews specifically commend friendly, helpful, and bubbly employees who create a fun atmosphere and provide excellent customer care, with some staff noted as inviting, kind, and an asset to the business. These interactions contribute to a positive and joyful visit, with one customer noting the personal attention and accommodating service, especially for catering orders. However, other visits are marked by less pleasant service, including staff described as not happy to be there, aggravated, and rude, which can break the experience. Issues with unmarked prices on items like coffee cups and hot sandwiches, as well as problems applying rewards discounts, have also been noted. The atmosphere is described as having a totally different vibe from night to morning, indicating inconsistency. Overall, the business is a destination for pizza and essentials, where the quality of the visit often hinges on the specific staff encountered.
Ibcant wait for the Caseys in Sullivan, MO to open!!!
August 2026
Massive pothole at the upper entrance is finally fixed! Also, on the weekends the army reserves are drilling be careful of camouflaged road hazards! Hitting one could result in being charged with destruction of government property.
August 2026
Good spot! Got the golden dumpling for grand baby for her 4th birthday