Casey's in Shelbina is known for having the best pizza, featuring made-from-scratch dough and fresh toppings. The store offers appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, coffee, groceries, and household essentials, along with quality fuels. Customers find the staff super friendly and note that everything is well-stocked and easy to find. The location is praised for its exceptionally clean restroom and parking lot. Many travelers find it a reliable and enjoyable stop, with high standards that make visits easy.
Haven’t had Casey’s pizza for 6 years due to the other stores not cooking properly that the crust was whiter than Casper. Stopped at this store to get drinks and the pizza looked good. BEST pizza we’ve had.
May 2025
Went to use the restroom while traveling and was like this was actually like the cleanest restroom I've ever been in. It even smelled clean!
July 2024
The fam had to go to the bathroom here. Great place! Zack signing off
