Casey's in Warrensburg, MO, located at 602 E Young Ave, is a popular spot for pizza, groceries, and fuel. Known for its made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings, the store offers delicious pizza for both delivery and pickup. Customers also enjoy a variety of appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and household essentials. The convenience store features quality fuels, making it a one-stop shop for many needs. Over the years, the store has improved significantly. Recently, it has become cleaner, more professional, and better organized. The takeout area with heaters provides fresh, nicely displayed food. Staff members are friendly, professional, and focus on good customer service, creating a positive atmosphere for regular visitors. Many customers appreciate the helpful and respectful employees, whether assisting with food orders or providing quick service at the gas pumps. The store also offers vegetarian options, with vegetarian pizzas and items available. Parking is plentiful, and wheelchair accessibility is available, although the presence of automatic doors is uncertain. While some customers find the food and service generally good, a few note that the pizza-making staff sometimes seem unenthusiastic about preparing whole pizzas, but cashiers remain consistently helpful. Overall, Casey's is viewed as a friendly, reliable place for food, drinks, and convenience needs.
Biggest gas/convenience store in Warrensburg. Myself, I like a little simpler place so I go to their other store.
December 2025
By far the best Casey's in warrensburg! The customer service is unbeatable. When the ice machine was working properly because it had slushed up and frozen over a staff member got up there and scooped some out for me. Thanks Bobby for everything that you do for all of warrensburg!
April 2025
I always feel very welcomed when I go into this Casey's. However, the one thing it is missing is their slushies because the machine is always broken.
