-
November 2025 by Ryley Marie
Ordering through the Casey’s app was simple and convenient, making the whole process stress-free. When we arrived, our Taco Pizza was hot, fresh, and ready right on time. The pizza itself was delicious — great flavor, perfect amount of toppings, and cooked just right.
The staff also did an excellent job. They were friendly, efficient, and made sure everything was prepared exactly as ordered. It’s always nice to have a smooth and satisfying experience from start to finish, and Casey’s delivered that today. We’ll definitely be back!
-
October 2025 by Vivvy
Been sitting here for about 20 minutes in their driveway. The food was supposed to be ready for pickup at 5:50, and some is just now coming out of the oven at 6:16. I'm not trying to be prissy or anything but all I've seen the workers do is come out and chat or vape, go back in, and repeat.
-
October 2025 by Jodi Mitchell
We ordered a pizza
-
July 2025 by Tracey Franklin
Ordered a few pizzas the other day and the man behind the counter james was very nice, very helpful and made sure I got my food within a couple minutes of getting there, although the other man behind the counter gave me dirty looks the whole time I waited for my food. Very nasty looking young man. Other than that, my experience was good.
-
June 2025 by Josh Turner
Never any food. Awful
-
April 2025 by Francine Trundel
A friend of mine placed a pizza order tonight for our girls wine night, and I went to pick it up, James at the counter was super friendly and made the experience really pleasant! The pizza looked great, perfectly cooked, with the toppings evenly spread and everyone loved it. Definitely planning to order again soon!
-
June 2024 by DeathdealersClan Gaming
Pizza is never ready on time. Then you arrive and they tell you they still have to make it. Even though they have no orders in front or behind you. I’ve come back to change my review it’s even worse now because they want you to pre-pay they don’t even trust you to get gas anymore now you get to stand out there for 45 minutes and wait for them to turn on the pump after you pre-pay just to go back inside after you guess how much fuel it’s going to take to fill up your car and pay them again ignorant pathetic . Feel like standing outside for 30 minutes while the employees mess around inside and never turn the gas pump on? This is the place to go multiple times per week happens can’t even gas up my work vehicle without standing here for 30 minutes pathetic. Back again to add to the review. Do not order pizza the older gentleman that works there will throw it at you through the car window.
-
March 2024 by Suzie Dudenhoeffer
Typical fast food pizza.
-
February 2024 by Joe Frisbie
Ordered pizzas, was 30 minutes later than told by the app, when I got home 15 miles later, was the wrong pizzas. Called the store and got passed around to a sparky rude manager who told me deal with it and hung up. Managers are rude and incompetent, and the cooks are always so high they can't talk let alone perform a duty of any kind. Customer Service doesn't exist in this country any more.
-
January 2024 by Monica Kellner
Christmas eve go to Casey’s to get a cold sandwich so I can have something to eat for Christmas. Casey is completely wiped out. There is no food anywhere prepared. What is the guy in the kitchen doing? I give this place a zero not Christmas to the customers.
-
January 2024 by Amy Bruegger
This place is my favorite! Cain Morgan is the best pizza maker ever! Only place I'll go for pizza!
-
November 2023 by JoAnn Freeman
They had the items I needed.
-
November 2023 by Crystal “ApacheLady2012” Lemke
Casey’s has great pizza!!!!! I’m from AZ and we cannot find great pizza especially from a gas station/ convenience store! What a great benefit to living in the Midwest!!!!! They have great donuts too but you gotta get here early!
-
October 2023 by William Meade
The Sedalia Missouri location is my favorite of all the Casey's I have visited. Great service and great quality food products. I'm eating pizza right now and loving it.
-
October 2023 by Gary Paden
My experience was not good . They had one checkout person on a lotto ticket night . My pepperoni and black olives pizza was dry and the black olives were just thrown in the middle of the pizza ,they didn't cover the whole pie.
