Casey's at 1005 E Highway 20 in O'Neill, NE offers popular pizza made with scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. The store also has appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and a variety of household essentials and groceries. Customers appreciate the friendly and hardworking staff who provide excellent customer service and make each visit enjoyable. The store is clean and well-maintained, with a decent bathroom. Gasoline is also available for fueling up. While most reviews highlight positive experiences, there is mention of a manager who was not as friendly and was sometimes mean to workers. Overall, Casey's is a convenient spot for pizza, groceries, and fuel in the area.
This store has gone through a lot of staffing issues, I think they finally got it! The last few times I stopped everyone was working, there was pizza and sandwiches even cookies and donuts. ALL AT THE SAME TIME!! Keep it up, it was good to get all my favorites in the same trip.
June 2026
My husband and I just stopped to grab coffee and some food for our long drive home to Minnesota. We were greeted by a very pleasant attendant. We had just left a sad event, and when Justin greeted us with a smile and welcome, our hearts were warmed. The world needs more Justins.
October 2025
I really appreciate the team here — they’re hardworking, friendly, and go above and beyond behind the counter. You can tell they take pride in their work. Excellent customer service every time. Thank you for making each visit a good one!
