-
June 2025 by Koltin Holling
3rd time ive ordered Pizza and paid for extra toppings that did not get put onto the pizza I ordered. This store used to be good, but the recent employees can't even read an order and assemble a pizza correctly. Cooler is also almost always bare with nothing you want to drink in it. Kid doing the register is always nice at night and I do respect the Manager the only good things I have to say.
-
February 2025 by Joann Principato
Great store. They have a kitchen and put out a number of different food options each day. They have excellent pizza. The coffee is always fresh. There is usually room at the gas pumps so there is no need to wait.
-
September 2024 by Jacob Korinek
Never any pizza at night! They should rehire all of night shift. Been this way for 2 1/2 years. Wilber deserves better! And would it hurt to clean the place parking lot/inside. I guess this is the world we live in where nobody cares.
-
August 2023 by Cody Meredith
Food is pretty good like other Casey's General Stores, staffing and service is always slow, gas seems to be higher here then other towns, only real place to stop if you need a pit stop.
-
February 2023 by Urban Mtndew
I had bought a Supreme and a taco pizza my taco pizza had none of the toppings called and they said they would remake it and all I got was containers that included the toppings didn't know I had to make my own pizza
-
September 2022 by Brady Smith
Had a perfectly made taco pizza along with the other pizzas.
-
August 2022 by Erin Dyas
Very disappointed with the pizza service. We ordered pizza online was told it would be ready in 40 minutes, arrived 15 minutes after estimated completion time and pizza was not done or even started!! Very disappointed, we will NO LONGER be ordering pizza from Caseys in Wilber.
-
July 2022 by Amber Does Things!
Said online open until midnight but when I was coming home from work at 10:30pm to get gas, they were completely closed.
-
September 2021 by Zomalia Fonseca
Excellent
-
September 2021 by P.J. Shaw
Blassy
-
September 2021 by Danny Dunaway
Good pizza
-
June 2021 by mary conway
Im a frequent flyer here having worked at the nearby school for several years. They stock almost anything you could ask for. If you had to, you could get all three meals a day here. Great coffee selection.
-
April 2021 by Heath Anthony
Just pulled up for gas. Store was open. Employees outside smoking. Pumps weren't turned on. I really needed to get gas.
-
January 2021 by Jamie Spradley
One stop shop.. gas, alcohol, cigarettes, limited groceries, candy, sandwiches, drinks, hot food
-
January 2021 by troy miller
Awesome pizza
