James' Original Salt Water Taffy is the best salt water taffy available, made for 140 years with love. It offers a wonderful variety and a good assortment of fudge and candies, with more flavors than many remember. Favorites include peanut butter, chocolate, butter rum, and the filled ones. You can buy a nicely wrapped box or choose your own flavors and pay by weight. The business has a few locations around Atlantic City, including inside the Tropicana Casino. The staff are very friendly, courteous, and helpful, providing excellent customer service. As a tip, a Caesars Rewards card can typically get a 10% off coupon. Some other candy seems a bit expensive, but the taffy itself is a favorite and makes people very happy to receive as a gift.
The taste of the taffy is not good! Especially the vanilla. Very disappointed in my online purchase!
December 2025
I have ordered 1lb. and 2 lb. boxes of salt water taffy as Christmas presents for the last few years. They come nicely wrapped, and people are very happy to receive the taffy. This year, there was a delivery problem due to the USPS, and I received excellent customer service from Terri.
June 2023
Bought loose, assorted taffy today, not cheap....all stale! What a huge disappointment. Note to retailers, if your overpriced product is not moving, don't sell it at a high price.
