-
March 2024 by Lori S.
Went on Saturday March 9 around 3pm to purchase a parakeet as a Birthday present for myself. 2 cashiers,no real lines to speak of. I asked an associate for some help with the parakeets. She went behind the counter and told the shift manager I needed help. Well, I was forgotten about. It seems only ,Tammy, the shift manager is the only store associate with the capability to get a keet out of a cage. According to the associate, when customers want a bird,"we just get Tammy". Sorry,thats ridiculous. I am also disabled and use a cane due to multiple joint replacements and Multiple Sclerosis. It hurts to walk but standing in 1 spot becomes excruciating. This was not a pleasant trip
-
February 2024 by Doyle Hunsinger
Everything you need for a pet
-
February 2024 by Sandy Durant
Friendly efficient staff. GREAT sale of 20% off the entire store this weekend!
-
February 2024 by Joe LaCarrubba
Great folks sorry to see them close
-
December 2023 by Jan K.
Always buy our dog food & treats here , love to get the coupons in the mail and use them , can't beat the discount.
-
December 2023 by Lorraine Bedson
All the folks at pet supply plus of Bayville are always the most excellent and helpful. People for a local business thank you for always having our Klondike
-
December 2023 by Kara F
I came into the store with a coupon from the back of a shoprite receipt. It was $5 off $35 or more OR $10 off $60 or more. After scanning all my items I’m told my total is $60.24. when I hand the cashier my coupon and say “I have this coupon” she doesn’t even look at it, and proceeds to type in a number for a coupon code. Then she says my total is $54 and change. I said well I have the $10 off coupon. Then another employee jumps in and says I’m only getting $5 off. I said well my total was over $60. Then I’m told I need to spend 8 more dollars to get $10 off. Because the total she was looking at was AFTER I was given some random discount that wasn’t on my coupon. 10 percent of $60.24 is around $6 so I assume the cashier typed in the 10 percent coupon. If either one of them took the time to look at the coupon I was using, they would have realized they gave me the wrong discount. It’s unfortunate and an innocent mistake but it’s annoying because that extra $5 off helps. I will be taking my business to the lanoka harbor pet supplies plus as they have always been more helpful and consistent.
-
November 2023 by Captain Drunk guy.
I like this place. It's everything you need in a big box pet store but family owned. Everyone's nice and helpful.
-
October 2023 by LInda Jakuboski
Came here today to look for a couple of items for my daughters hermit crab. Did not find anything. A young girl, who is an employee, walked by me and said nothing. No hello can I help you find something..nothing. She looked miserable. Not going back to this store. Rather go to Petsmart or Petco.Also.saw a big guinea pig in a small enclosure. Horrible!!
-
October 2023 by Missy Agnes Jennings
Great staff, Ally is such a great groomer. She does a beautiful job and knows just how to handle her. My dog doesn't stress and that is a great piece of mind.
-
August 2023 by Marilyn SS
I only bring my two Labs to the grooms at Pet Supply Plus...my girls love them.And these two grooms do such a great job with them.Thank you?♥️
-
August 2023 by Shannon Sandstrom
Patience kindness and caring. The ladies who handle Koa's nail trimming have their hands full with the 40lb old man yest they display the impitamy of patience, kindness, and caring. Thank you
-
August 2023 by Joe Ciampoli
Excellent and caring staff. Our Cleo approves
-
July 2023 by Wendi Higgins
Great place for your pets. Prices are reasonable, and they have frequent kitten adoptions. Truly a place that loves animals.
-
July 2023 by steve harder
My crickets always die when I get them here. And I wouldn’t buy an aquatic plant from here either
