-
January 2024 by Christine E.
Went there the other day to look for a birthday gift. I found each staff I encountered very helpful, thoughtful, and pleasant. I had to go back the second time on that same day as I changed my mind on the gift and they happily accepted the return and were so helpful with what I purchased. I would go back to this place, I love their inventory, they just had more stock of the type of wines and champagne I was looking for.
-
December 2023 by Lee S.
I'm sad to write this review as this used to be my favorite place to show for wines, and they have a great cheese selection too. But the last few trips the customer service has really gone downhill. There are many other local shops that I've found in the area with similar selections and prices and MUCH better service. The issue really became clear when there was a problem with something I purchased (a scotch tasting set for a holiday gift). One of the bottles Included was wrong, but they offered a lot of push back on returning, even accusing me of tampering with it. No apology, no offer to make up for it - just attitude from the staff and manager. Again sad to see a once great place go so far downhill.
-
November 2023 by John E McCarthy
Great selection and for the most part reasonable prices, staff is always very helpful
-
October 2023 by Camp Becca Dogs
I'm not a wine connoisseur nor do I even imbibe that often however they are so kind, and respectful of what I want to spend and the best thing to pick on a given occasion or if I'm giving as a gift.
-
October 2023 by Andrew Wildrick
Great experience. Very friendly and helpful employees. Wonderful inventory of wines, snacks, cheeses and holiday gifts.
-
September 2023 by Nick Didenko
Amazing selection of Italian wines while prices are reasonable. Attractive, clean, looking like new store. Store managers are very helpful
-
August 2023 by judy lopes
Fun wine tasting for sugarless wine. Nice deli food. Cashier very friendly. Great range of wine selection. Everyone available to be very helpful. They don’t just point they walk you to you where you need to go and point out options you might not have thought of and alert you to items similar on sale that you may not be aware of.
-
August 2023 by Sunny Orchid
Gary’s wine is my favorite places for all my alcohol need from cheap wine to high end, everyday vodka to rare aquavit.
-
August 2023 by Mark Silber
What a delightful place to visit and shop. Staff is plentiful and so delightful. They don't hang together and avoid contact with customers as is the case in so many box stores. Every last one of them will stop what they're doing and walk you to what you need. Selection across the entire spectrum is excellent, the store, including the cheese and deli department are spotless. Most of the time, Gary's can get what you want if it's not in stock. They got me a red Montrachet and now are trying to get me French Griottines - a large liter jar of morello cherries in kirsch, great with ice cream and true old fashioned hot fudge. Sandwiches are on gourmet bread from NY and carefully made as you request for a very reasonable price. Gary's even has a modest selection of half bottles, most of which are on sale, something scarce as hen's teeth. My review is limited to my experience at the Bernardsville store.
-
July 2023 by Philip R.
Let me get this off my chest to begin with; I rarely walk out of Gary's having spent less than $100. The reason: and incredible range of wines, beers, liquors and foods for almost every palette. If at first glance you can't find what you want invariably one of the dozens of staff will know how to find what you need. Now. The reason for my leaky wallet. The British snack section. Crisps. Real chocolate not the waxy barf nonsense Hershey sells. Biscuits, salad cream, mincemeat. I'm not going to go one but it's fantastic to sate the homesickness. Beer section is great, wine section greater and the cheesemonger is excellent. You can't go wrong here.
-
June 2023 by Dave S.
I've been here perhaps 10-20 times. The selection of alcoholic products is very solid, then there's the cheeses and associated deli products, plus I like the English candy section. Prices are quite competitive.Why the 2 star review? OMG the staff here are just awful, the organization of the store equally torturous. If you need help, the staff are either borderline arrogant, nope change that - they act ridiculously superior - or they see you are trying to catch their eye and they walk away. Checking out has become a ridiculous snaking walk to join a line of 4+ customers served by 1 cashier. Asking for a gift wrap on a $200 bottle of champagne receives a request for a $4 wrapping fee.I will still go here because of the stock but holy Batman why don't the management have a clue as to how painful this store is ?
-
June 2023 by Nick Boxter
Went to the physical store many years ago, first time ordering online & same seemingly infinite selections online as in the store. Delivery was fast, within the stated 2 hour time, and exactly as I indicated in the notes section. Excellent experience and I have my go to place in Bernardsville now.
-
April 2023 by Fred Hochberg
Great wines. Great prices. Frustrating website and ordering process. When online you don’t care which of the five stores you’re ordering from. This adds complexities and usually requires customer service to intervene. They do a great job. But it marks the experience. And takes more time
-
April 2023 by de lee
Gary’s Wine and Marketplace is outstanding! I was especially impressed with Brian, their delivery person and associate. He was very knowledgeable, helpful and accommodating. I highly recommend Gary’s their products are very good and extremely, priced reasonably!
-
March 2023 by Randy Grote
Always a great experience shopping here. Staff is very helpful and knowledgeable. Best selection of wines in NJ from outstanding lower price to the best of the best from all regions and styles.
