502 Baking Company is a beloved local bakery that offers a wide range of sweet treats and savory options. Their mini key lime pie, made with a perfect gluten-free crust, stands out, while their key lime pie pops are heavenly. The crumb cake is a must-try, especially the gluten-free version, and the peanut butter cookies and chocolate chip cookies are also highly praised. Savory choices like bacon, cheddar maple scones are divine, and the sourdough bread is a hit among customers. Fresh, high-quality ingredients and skillful preparation make every bite a delight. The bakery is known for its welcoming atmosphere, and customers appreciate the friendly service from the family that owns it.
My wife and I had a cheesecake crumb slice from here. It was absolutely outstanding.
We had never visited under the old ownership so not much to compare there but this was a great little spot and what we had was outstanding!
December 2025
Fantastic bakery! Stopped in for the rainbow cookie crumb cake which was phenomenal! Couldn't leave without an assortment of cookies brownies and other crumb cakes! We'll definitely be a regular here
June 2025
Great OG coffee cake, Best keylime Pie I have tasted.
