-
January 2024 by Tracylee Hertzog
It tasted good, but it was very expensive. The hot chocolate was just ok. Chocolate was good.Wheelchair accessibility: For the most part, Cape May is not wheelchair friendly. The shops are small and crowded with things
-
December 2023 by Angela
We used to drive an hr for your peanubutter until my fiance passed in August, now I order.
-
November 2023 by BrittStoff
Delicious, excellent staff!
-
November 2023 by James Leon
Absolutely lovely. The staff was so sweet and friendly! Loved the honey and my dogs enjoyed their peanut butter dog
-
November 2023 by Luke Johnson
Super fun. All sorts of peanut related products along with other great items.
-
October 2023 by MigratoryMidlands
Selling all things peanut butter related, but we were disappointed that there was no coffee available (it had apparently ”finished”) and that there was little that was unusual or novel in the products.
-
October 2023 by Tiffany Ann Speakman
I bought this one to hold me over until my favorite cappuccino peanut butter was back in stocks! As always the Cape May Peanut Butter Company never disappoints! I even place online orders throughout the year because it would cost more than tolls and gas to get down so in between vacations, I place orders online! I have never tasted a bad batch in the store and my dog absolutely LOVES their peanut butter dog treats!
-
October 2023 by C T
I bought their Bananas Foster small-batch/high-price peanut butter. Flavor was ok, not great, but the TEXTURE WAS HORRIBLE. It felt like dried peanuts in your mouth, definitely NOT SPREADABLE. And their labeling doesn't have nutrition facts or even the company address...how is that even legal??
-
September 2023 by Marjorie Oquendo
Great peanut butter product, love picking them up in person as Smithville is a very cute place to visit. But staff at the store always seem to be annoyed. Not a pleasant experience. Work on that or close up shop.
-
September 2023 by Peace Peace
Very rude staff, walked out. Tried a few times to go in , thought well maybe just a bad day ! Seems like they have a lot of bad days!!! Seemed like you were bothering them. Also cookies have been stale every time we have gotten them !! Tried to call and talk to manager , they were to busy to talk .
-
August 2023 by Dana Salvatore
Cookies are DRY as a desert. Do not let the smell of this place fool you. Are they serving cookies that are days old?? There’s no reason why the cookies should be this stale and stiff.Staff wasn’t that friendly either. I felt as though they just wanted me to leave, and I was an inconvenience to their day.Really not a great experience at all.
-
August 2023 by Trevor collinsworth
Cookies in the case are hard as a rock. Peanut butter is good though. Bought some cookies though hard as a rock asked for refund and still haven’t received it. Customer service is very poor.
-
August 2023 by btmochnal
Very friendly and informative staff. Samples were welcome and helped to make decisions. Appreciate the small jars of PB.
-
August 2023 by Rick Broyles
I absolutely love this place. Everything I have is delicious. I have had the peanut butter cups, the super large peanut butter cups, The cookies, but my absolute favorites are the peanut butter nonpereils, peanut butter cookie dough peanut butter, and the peanut butter marshmallow.
-
July 2023 by Kate
Seems like they have awesome peanut butter and flavors of such. However we just got a cookie and scone here but they were pretty dry so I wouldn’t recommend getting their baked goods. Service was also not incredibly friendly
