-
March 2024 by Roberto Singson
My first time trying this pizza.its the best in town. Love
-
March 2024 by G P
Just moved to Rutherford TODAY and I’m not used to having good pizza in NJ, I prefer NYC slices. Ordered a few pies this afternoon for all our friends and family who are helping us move and I needed to take a few minutes to write this review. So excited that this is my new fav pizza place! Pepperoni, Plain, and Sausage is so tasty!! Love the pepperoni cups that curl up! ❤️❤️❤️
-
February 2024 by cristina careri
First time ordering from here since it was close to my house . I ordered a cheese pie and it came disgusting . Pizza had the cheese falling off and it was all mushed together you couldn’t even make out slices . I called the shop and the guy picked up and I told him what happened he said I have to ask for well done .. I said I’m not ordering steak I’m ordering pizza I never had to do that .. he goes you know what don’t call here and order no more… there’s many pizza places around with good service .. will NOT be spending money here with rude people
-
February 2024 by Lonnie
Food is good and customer service is
-
December 2023 by Joe Fisicaro
Best meatball parm around hands down. Their pizza is also great can’t go wrong there. Only thing they close too
-
December 2023 by Kelly Mikulski
So glad we opted for this tiny hidden gem! You couldn’t find more down home , authentic Italian cuisine if you hoped a plane. Save the trip and travel to Carlstadt in NJ. no fuss, no muss, like it’s fresh out of Grandma’s kitchen. What you’d expect of her Sunday sauce topped the Sicilian style “Grandma” pizza, complete with fresh mozzarella, torn fresh basil leaves and a perfect crisp & tasty crust.We couldn’t stop without trying owner Johnny’s award winning “best meatball” which did not disappoint. Wonderfully accompanied by a touch of fresh ricotta, we had to take a couple to go home for mom.Johnny and friends entertained us with some friendly chit chat; it felt like you were stopping at a cousin’s for Sunday dinner. We’ll be back, and likely with a bigger cooler to take advantage of a few extras to travel back upstate with us. We look forward to our next visit!Kelly & Scott
-
December 2023 by James Fitzpatrick
My daughter and I stopped here between soccer games and were glad we did. Perhaps the best slice of pizza I’ve ever had. Same with the meatballs. Service couldn’t have been friendlier. It’s my 7 year old’s new favorite restaurant.
-
November 2023 by Michael Thomas
Very delicious pizza! I was a bit hesitant when I drove up but it was definitely worth it!
-
November 2023 by webster moyle
This place is Amazing. Easily one of the best pizza’s I’ve ever had. The atmosphere is great and so is the owner. When I walked in I was offered a Zeppole, and I felt like I was at home.I will be back soon to try the meatball.Thank you from San Diego!
-
October 2023 by Mark T.
At first I was skeptical because of the $13 price tag on the meatball parm, but after hearing the reviews of these amazing meatballs, I had to try it. Let me tell you, it's worth $13 and more. Holy meatball, these are the best I've ever had. Perfection and highly recommended!!!
-
October 2023 by Shea Flynn
Our son loves the planes going by! Great
-
October 2023 by Mike Meistrich
Owner was very nice. Food was delicious. Will definitely be back to try the
-
October 2023 by Tom B.
Order cancelled over an hour after it was placed. Placed the order on Slice. They accepted the order! I contacted SLice and they said the restaurant said they were closing early. This is what they do all the time!!! Ridiculous. Oh, by the way the food is good but I will never order from them again.
-
September 2023 by Mike S.
Great pizza spot that definitely uses fresh ingredients. Even better staff, extremely friendly! Its on the corner of a residential area with limited seating, so i'd go there for takeout or for a quick slice. If i lived in the area, this would be my go to pizza place.
-
September 2023 by Master J.
This place was pretty bad.Meat balls were ok at best.Inside is dirty.Pizza was burnt.I will not be coming back.