-
December 2023 by Nicholas
I went to him not knowing much about card prices.. so I sold to him.. found out later they were worth so much more.. I understand making money but being a complete con man is another thing.. I would never recommend this guy for anything
-
August 2023 by Andre
Dude has horrible customer service… he was on the phone when I walked in and I had a meeting going on, on my phone. He said “is there a reason you have that on? You better spend money at my store!” Awful thing to say to someone who comes by your shop on a visit from out if state. Everything is old and over priced.
-
August 2023 by Ken Patera
I came in with 23 1965 topps football BGS and SGC graded. Some 9s majority were 8 and 7s. The owner Fred said no one’s looking for the old stuff. Everything today is the new cards.I had a 7.5 BBG Namath. He offered me 125 for all 23 cards!!!!!
-
July 2023 by Wayne Ferris
Not sure why this store has bad reviews. I talked to the owner Fred. A real nice guy. A true 80s legend. He Told me about how he would sell truck loads of Donruss back in the 80s and the cameo he made in the movie full grown bushes 4. I got 2 boxes of old 80s wax at a great price and had a great time.
-
July 2023 by Robert Heenan
Me and my girlfriend stopped by with some of 1980s cards I found in my basement to sell. We went in to ask if he wanted to see the cards. He said let me see your girls cans and after I look at them I will look at the cards. What nerve!
-
June 2023 by Harry Balsac
Went into the store to sell my Casey Mize Bowman BGS Auto Rainbow collection to put towards my girlfriends new cans.The suspension blew out on my car pulling onto his gravel dirt driveway off of route 18.He gave me 200 for the collection. My shocks and struts cost 1800. Left in the red and much further away to staring at a nice rack.
-
January 2023 by Bob Boner
Walked in and I saw a man who was one more whopper away from cardiac arrest. Store had a stench of spoiled cottage cheese and 3 week old shrimp. Saw the amount of dust on the cards and a price tag of 350 on a topps series 1 hobby and I left. Enough said.
-
September 2022 by PJ Pape
Went in to the store with my brother the guy had extremely bad prices, was rude and didn’t know what he was talking about. He claimed that we were talking in circles probably has dementia.
-
July 2022 by Joseph Clementi
Great football talk and awesome selection. Competitive pricing. Such a great find!
-
February 2022 by Paul D
A true legend in the biz. Been buying from him since 2009. Plenty of product new and old, competitive pricing. Always willing to make deal.His knowledge about the hobby is unmatched. I recommend Mr D’s to anyone looking to buy or sell.
-
November 2021 by Ryan Simio
This guy is the best, great prices…awesome selection of wax…and both our dogs were named Namath! Will be a repeat customer for years to come
-
October 2021 by Joseph Thomas
Good Guy, I went there about two months ago in order to get my feet wet again, I was a big collector in my youth... Will be making reoccurring purchases.
-
September 2021 by Harry P. Ness
Could not believe the arrogance of this shop owner! I brought in my 80s baseball collection to sell. The owner Fred took a look and said give me a second. He goes to the restroom for 15 minutes and comes back. He says I appraised your collection and let’s talk. Follow me. He takes me into the restroom points to the toilet and says that’s what I think of it.I saw there was a fresh deuce in the bowl.
-
September 2021 by Brian Bieman
Cool store, but the owner came off as very rude. I’ve never left a review anywhere, so this store has left an impression. I’ll try my luck elsewhere.Brought a list of cards that I was looking to sell and had the PSA values (from grades 4-10) listed as reference for myself. He immediately was offended and started lecturing me about how I should do more research and how my list is bs. He said “nobody wants this s**t”. Weird because I have offers for some of my cards already (Walter Payton, Montana rookies etc)I wasn’t even asking for the psa amount, was just using it for my reference of the value of cards so I could have an educated conversation. Once he realized this, he was a bit easier to deal with but still such a bad start. As a customer looking to bring both the store and myself some business he was too confrontational. Knowledgeable guy just abrasive and rude.
-
August 2021 by julio ramos
I didn’t even get to the point where “Freddy” even looked at my collection from the early 90’s. Basically over the phone I asked him his opinion on if what I have is even worth looking at. He said he’ll charge me $5 for each card I want looked at. Super arrogant along with the typical Jersey boy accent. Straight nasty on the phone. He seriously told me whatever I have, take what it’s worth and he’ll give me 30-40% of its value. Don’t bother with this place until you try ANYWHERE else first!