Toy Stores near Egg Harbor, NJ

“You truly never know what you're going to find at Ollie's. Are you in the market for a new cuckoo clock? Or perhaps some extremely niche cereal. Maybe you're a fan of the 90s dungeons & dragons cartoon! It is always worth a visit just to see what they have and at the very least stock up on cheap and exotic snacks. I know they are the whims of their suppliers but I would love to see a larger manga section.”

“The owners, Justin and Penelope, are incredible—friendly, welcoming, and extremely knowledgeable. I reached out via email to inquire about selling a few items, and to my surprise (and appreciation), I received a prompt, thoughtful response. Penelope clearly explained the process, answered my questions, and scheduled an appointment without any hassle. In today’s world, that level of responsiveness is rare and refreshing.

When I arrived for my appointment, Justin took the time to walk me through how he evaluates and prices items. He was transparent, patient, and fair throughout the entire process. Having visited another store previously where pricing felt unclear and rushed, this experience stood out in the best way. We came to an agreement that felt honest and mutually respectful.

Even if you’re not looking to sell, Farpoint Toys is absolutely worth a visit. Justin has begun curating what is essentially a museum of 70s, 80s, and 90s toys—a must-see for anyone who loves nostalgia. Walking through the store brought back memories of childhood in the best possible way, and the selection available for purchase is impressive.

I can’t recommend Farpoint Toys enough. Whether you’re buying, selling, or simply reminiscing, you’ll leave with a smile and the pleasure of having met people who truly appreciate vintage toys and the memories attached to them.”

“This is the best place to be for anyone that loves books & bookish things. Along with other non-book items. It was my first time in the store and I wanted to buy some much. They have a huge variety of all types of books. Great store!!”

“An adorable selection of doll clothes and accessories. (Not to mention some nice dolls) I got a small nee doh ice cube for 3 dollars. The person at the register was nice. Lots of different fidgets and things in addition to doll supplies.”

“I loved everything about this location. The store clerk/cashier was amazing. The store was clean, and not cluttered. I would recommend this location to all. Again, the store clerk was amazing, just wish I knew her name. I'm sure you can find out, she deserves an award for her impeccable customer service skills.”

“This store has such an incredible selection of toys and other items... Music boxes, board games, puzzles, old school toys. My kids got a squishie and a cute pair of earrings. You can find something here for just about anyone that has a fun side.

Also, the shop owner is very kind. We went in just before a big downpour (workout realizing it), probably right around closing time, and he gave us a heads up that the storm was coming and invited us to stay until the downpour was over. That's how we had the time to really look around and see what all is available here.

What a cool shop to explore!”