-
February 2024 by vernon koslow
Definitely on the overpriced side. Big selection though.
-
September 2023 by Jack N.
Store can use some refreshening.Staff is however nice
-
July 2023 by Elad Shushan
Haven’t been here in a while. Owner great guy and easy to work a deal with. Will be back ?
-
May 2023 by Aidan O'Reilly
The best sports memorabilia shop in the area. Good people and good stuff.
-
April 2023 by Masin Lewis
My friend went then I went and it was filled with cardsAnd had good prices but they should add the wax era cards
-
December 2022 by Mitchel Vigil
Got 2 boxes of Czx middle earth that the seller said were not factory sealed but the contents untouched. That was a lie. The packs were all resealed and contents missing. No sketch cards and no auto cards. Will not buy from again.
-
December 2022 by Mitch V.
Bought 2 Czx middle earth boxes. The box wasn't factory sealed but I was assured the cards in the box were sealed and untouched. That was a lie. Packs were opened and resealed. Missing all autograph cards and sketch cards. Did deal on PayPal G&S so filed a claim. I will remove all bad feedback once refunded my $547
-
May 2022 by Dhruv Parmar
Owner is not friendly and not respectful. Plus the overpriced products.Asked me to leave the store after 5 minutes saying this was not a "hangout spot." I was alone in the store. I will not be returning.
-
May 2022 by adam Kowenicki
Sold me a fake Derek jeter gold hologram rookie for 1200 dollars I sent it away to psa to get it verified they told me it was a fake. Called him up says I’m out of luck nothing he will do. He is a scammer don’t buy from him or his ebay store. He is a conman. Who likes to take advantage of his customers. Especially don’t pay him cash ever .
-
April 2022 by Adam K.
Scammed by this man sold me a fake jeter gold hologram card I sent it to psa to get verified they said it was a fake I called him up to let him know he said I'm out of luck and he's keeping my 1200 dollars never use his store or ebay store and especially never give him cash. Rude and now I have to bring him to court he is a con artist who sells fake cards
-
January 2022 by Jason Porter
Poor communication, rude and unresponsive to messages. I would not recommend anyone doing business with America’s pastime. After reading some of these reviews, I’m probably lucky the card I intended to purchase fell thru.
-
December 2021 by Jason Porter
Poor communication and unresponsive to messages.
-
October 2021 by Cooper Gordon
Amazing place, owner was super nice and we hope to come back
-
May 2021 by Francis Ventura
Great place and great price! Always find something your looking for and a very knowledgeable owner!
-
May 2021 by Chris Champy
Excellent inventory, friendly staff
