Cafasso's Fairway Market is a long-standing business known for its high-quality products, though it has a mixed reception. The store offers a wide variety of items, including lots of Italian style products, a nice selection of cheese and produce, and very good organic products. Shoppers praise the fresh delicious breads, famous in-store made mozzarella, prepared food selection, and cakes. The staff is generally described as very friendly and helpful. However, the store is often over crowded with merchandise and people, with very narrow aisles that make shopping difficult. Some customers report a very bad smell in the store. While the quality is high, it is not a bargain basement. A notable criticism is that workers begin packing items off the shelf well before the 7PM weekday closing time, sometimes leaving shelves empty while customers are still shopping. Despite some negative points, many recommend it for quality, noting plenty of parking available.
Love the fresh bread and focaccia. Have a great selection of items but is SO EXPENSIVE!
May 2026
Once I enter, I feel I went back in time to a beautiful spot in my heart. Love to shop there
May 2026
Small grocery store that has lots to offer. Especially their prepared foods. Quick check out service. Truly enjoy the short ribs. So tender and tasty..