-
September 2023 by Pickle_Live
Pizza was very thick and not very good. Extremely overpriced. Would not recommend. Waiter was extremely rude.
-
September 2023 by David Waldman
Food was delicious, unfortunately we went on a busy holiday weekend when they were understaffed & things didn’t quite go our way.
-
September 2023 by Lisa D
Three of us went to dinner here and each got drinks. The bartenders were maybe 21 and it showed in the drinks, definitely not worth the price. We ordered the toasted gnocchi app but they were pretty burnt, the sauce was good. The dipping oil was gross, no flavor and drops of balsamic, bread wasn't even worth the calories. We ordered the white mushroom and rosemary pizza, it was more than enough to share with the french fries. The pizza was good but extremely oily, the fries were fine. We sat outside after getting our first drink at the bar. It wasn't that busy but the wait staff was scarce and difficult to get their attention. The water was served in plastic cups with a water carafe but no ice. Uncertain if I'd return honestly because of the cost and the kids running the place.
-
August 2023 by Marissa A.
Food was good but they are understaffed so expect long wait times! Our table shared the house and ceaser salad. The homemade garlic butter croutons are delicious. We also shared the original pie pizza and we highly recommend trying at least one of the pizzas! Our table was super close to the one next to us and people kept bumping the pizza board. I recommend asking for an outside table as the inside tables are really close to each other. Those who ordered the chicken parm loved it! There are different types of sauce to choose from based on your preference. The entree came with 3 housemate gnocchis. We had to wait longer for these as they didn't come out with our meals. They were super mushy but still delicious in the blush sauce. We also shared the sausage and peppers dish that had a mix of spicy and mild- highly recommend! For drinks, we had the saltwater martini- their version of a watermelon martini. Super sweet but good! Our table also liked the bourbon lemonade. Drinks took forever so if it's busy, be mindful when ordering your second round.Bill was about $300 for a party of 6 with a few drinks. I'd only go back on a non busy weeknight.
-
August 2023 by Jas JellybeanDorilla
Great food, especially the pizza. It is super soft. so so so soft. They are famous for their square pizza. And that is coming from a New Yorker. Anyways, the staff is cheery in general, but sometimes they make the atmosphere a bit too fast paced; however, the bar is the main contributor to the fast paced atmosphere. Furthermore, the bar is not loud as it goes for bars, so that is good
-
August 2023 by NikkiVixx_333
We dined At Saltwater Restaurant at the end of August on a Friday night,although it was very busy all of our food was served excellent
-
August 2023 by Karen M.
Well I think I found my favorite Pizza and Caesar Salad. My husband and I decided to try something different for a change for our usual takeout Monday night pizza. I'm glad we did. We ordered the square Italian Vegetable and a Caesar Salad. Absolutely delicious!!!!
-
August 2023 by Aaron
Absolutely love this place. Best pizza on the island and everything else is delicious. My only knock would be the prices are very high, even for margate standards.
-
August 2023 by Julie Sebastian
The pizza here is phenomenal. Hands down the best pizza i have ever had. It’s thick, crunchy, just so so good. I get the pepperoni square pizza and I go to heaven every time i bite into it. I gave them 4 stars though because i got the Milan salad with shrimp and for $19 it was pretty lame. Dressing was good but they gave me three medium size shrimp that weren’t even sautéed, just seemed like they took them out of a container from Giant. But i learned my lesson… just get the pizza!
-
August 2023 by Sean Simpson
Food was incredible! Try the square pizza the best no reason this should not be 5.0!
-
August 2023 by Sam Valenza
Nice night out. No stress. Sarah was great. Good service..food.. glad we went!!!
-
August 2023 by William G.
Let me start by saying if there was a 10 star this restaurant deserves it, I have been coming here for over 5 years 3 times a week, I tried everything on the menu and never had a bad meal in fact the ingredients these guys use are unlike any other Italian restaurant I have been to. Also I'd like to say that reading all of these new negative reviews there is an old saying good food is worth the wait me personally I'd wait 2 hours or more to get my food from here ITS THAT GREAT!!!!!! SALTWATER keep up the great hard work and try to disregard all this negativity that these haters are writing on here!!!!
-
August 2023 by Grace M.
Do not eat here!!! This restaurant is horrible and the management absolutely sucks. I came to eat dinner here to celebrate passing my real estate exam. We arrived at around 6:45 and and ordered right away since we were starving. After about 30 minutes we started to get concerned that our table had been forgotten since we had no bread and ran out of water while all of the tables around us were being served and our waitress was nowhere to be found. About 15 minutes later we finally get her attention and she tells us the kitchen is backed up, however a group behind us who sat after about 20 minutes after we did had already gotten their food. She gave us no time estimate and just walked away.Finally about another 20 minutes later all of our appetizers and entrees arrived at once of course except for the one thing I ordered and my main meal which was a round pizza. The waitress said it was on its way shortly but after about another 15 minutes and after everyone in my group finished there food there was still no pizza. And to add insult to injury, the table next to us that were seated about 30 minutes after us had gotten that exact kind of pizza and all of there food already. Finally, we pointed this out to our waitress and she left then came back and said she brought this up and there was no explanation. She also said she wanted to be transparent with us and said the pizza would probably be another 15 minute and we would have to wait and they could do us the favor of boxing it up.At this point everyone was completely finished so we asked if we could cancel the pizza. So I had to leave the table and my family to run to Pierre's pizza a block away since I was so hungry and a storm was coming in soon. And on the way back, I got caught in the rain and my pizza got soaked. Finally, to top this all off they did not apologize or say anything!! And not that they were required to do so, but nothing was taken off our check, we were not given a free dessert, or anything. So it can suffice to say that I will not be coming back here. The pizzas I have had here in the past were extraordinarily oily and not good, so I was probably better off eating at Pierres anyway.
-
August 2023 by Kim R.
Perfect restaurant! This is an amazing restaurant to go to with family, on a date, or even have a small event. We have been enjoying this restaurant for a couple of years. We love the Caesarand Milan salads, the Gnocchi, the square and NEW round pizzas. My personal favorite is the mushroom rosemary pizza!! Delicious! My kids love the Chicken Parmesan and NEW fries. The cannoli's and zeppoli are always a sweet treat to end the night. This place is amazing. The owners have hearts of gold and care for our family like they would their own. We have food allergies and Lori and David as well as Chef David have taken the utmost care of us and always keep us safe:) They are so knowledgeable about every ingredient in the restaurant.The staff are always attentive, friendly and helpful. When you go into this restaurant you feel like you are walking in to a fun family gathering:)I had my 50th birthday celebration here last summer- we had about 25 people and everyone enjoyed their meals and we had an awesome time. The staff was amazing for my celebration as always! I cant say enough about this place- we love it - it is our favorite place to go with our family :)
-
August 2023 by Jen McErlean
The staff couldn’t be any more attentive. Drinks and atmosphere are wonderful. Food is great. Could not recommend this restaurant any more. Music was great. Great place for dinner