-
January 2024 by Victoria Dodd
A true gem that has been in business for 50 years! Sam and Rick are very sweet and our sandwich’s tasted so fresh and delicious! They have a lot of great options. We will definitely be going back.
-
December 2023 by Nicole Tignor
Great people, delicious homemade chili, farm-fresh meats, old-world flavor!
-
October 2023 by Chris Vrabel
Owners are great friendly guys.Food is delicious.Everything is homemade.You gotta put it on your list.
-
June 2023 by Kris S
The owner of this establishment approached me to say I did not look disabled even with my legal handicap plaque parked out front his store. Truly unkind and unprofessional. Will never give business or will anyone I know in town.
-
May 2023 by Paul Rocheny
Fantastic family owned Deli great selection and spotless! Can't wait to go back.
-
May 2023 by Carol S.
we've lived about a 15 minute walk away for over 27 years. this place has never gone down in quality. my son grew up loving the Reuben's and now lives in CA and still heads there for a Reuben whenever he comes home. It's his first food stop on his eating tour of NJ every trip. Honestly, every sandwich we've had is fantastic and good value in a small, overpriced town. Impressed with the consistency. It isn't fancy but the quality is there.
-
February 2023 by Paul M.
Love this place. I've been getting sandwiches from here for over a decade. Small family business. The thing that sets their sandwiches apart is the bread from Hoboken. Great Italian bread. Not soft and fluffy. I'm
-
January 2023 by Warren Bobrow
Lucky to have a place that cares about each ingredient. Nice people. Prime meat.
-
January 2023 by Alessandro Mannino
Walking into this place feels like stepping into a Time Machine back to the 70s and I couldn’t love it more. Have mainly tried their sandwiches which are loaded with meat and cheese and a very good size. Sam and his son are great to talk to as well when I stop by.
-
October 2022 by Michael Carr
My wife and I just stopped in to get an Italian sub best sandwich in town!
-
June 2022 by Peron405
one of my fav sandwich shops I love almost everything they have
-
February 2022 by John Oblad
Discovered them looking for a Sloppy Joe. So much better than the Millburn Deli. Old time family owned business.
-
November 2021 by Jack K
The Colonial Pantry is a Mendham treasure. I have never had a bad sandwich or platter. You have to visit this deli when ever you have time.
-
July 2021 by Lorraine Bostrom
This place took me back in time ! Had a wonderful conversation with the owners and the best deli sandwich. This place is an absolute gem with old school products and service. I pray this family owned business stays for decades to come.
-
June 2021 by Matthew Schreiner
Having grown up in Mendham the sloppy joe has been a family favorite for years. I was finally able to return after 26 years and have the original and it's even better then I remember. Everything is sliced to order and is so thin without falling apart it almost melts when you eat it. Can't wait to return!
