Pet Stores in Middletown, NJ

“My husband and I had been searching for a Biewer Terrier for some time and came across one at The Pet Shoppe in Middletown in December of 2022. I FaceTimed my husband from the store and we agreed that I was going to bring her home and we named her Elvira. Well, Elvira is a spirited puppy with three older sisters, all different breeds. She fit right in as the baby. We noticed around July 2023 that she was favoring her right hind leg. Through pathology with the vet we determined that she had a congenital issue called Leggs-Calves-Perthes syndrome and she had to have a femoral head ostectomy. I contacted Dana, the owner of The Pet Shoppe to explain the situation. Dana, immediately offered to help financially. Please know that she was not legally obligated to do so. The "Lemon Law" for pets expires once they hit 6 months of age and I believe only applies to pets purchased at a licensed pet store. Regardless, Dana, stepped up, she explained that she stands by her dogs and that she would assist us with the medical bills, which were adding up. Needless to say Elvira made a full recovery and uses her leg superbly now. I can't recommend Dana and The Pet Shoppe enough. They are licensed and regulated by the State of New Jersey, other "stores" in the area are actually kennels and are not regulated by the State nor do you have the same coverage as a consumer. That all said, buy from a reputable licensed pet store like The Pet Shoppe, NOT an unregulated kennel.”

“I usually shop at Monroe Tractor Supply, because it’s close to my home, but they didn’t have an item I wanted. I made a trip to the Middletown store and was pleasantly surprised at how the store was fully stocked with everything! The best part of my experience was being waited on by a personable and polite employee named Tom who provided me excellent customer service! I highly recommend this store for your holiday shopping or daily needs. I’ll be back for sure. Thank you Tom!”

“Your store has improved and I would rate it as an A+. Your stock is full, your associates are friendly and knowledgeable and your store cleanliness is great. I didn’t catch the name of your associate who checked us out but he was so kind and friendly to me and my adult son, who has autism.Thank you for creating a nice shopping environment and kudos to your employees…especially your associate who helped us at the register!!”

“While traveling from Nebraska, I stopped into Cosmopawlitan to buy my little girl something special. I had a pleasant conversation with the owner and purchased some items with her recommendations. Both items were well received and are in the new toy rotation. The shop was very well organized and stocked. Thank you for all the help”

“Best Place to get a Puppy!We got our lab here years ago and today my Mom is coming home with the most adorable 9week old wheaten terrier.Staff Especially Jenifer is amazing and works each family different. You won’t be disappointed.Come by and say hi to the staff and they will find your the perfect pet for you.”