-
March 2024 by Michael Mercanti
One of the best Italian restaurants in the area. Never disappointed. BYOB makes it even better. Zucchini appetizer was very good
-
March 2024 by Michael
Wonderful for date night, couples or family. White linen table cloths, candlelight and a great staff along with tremendous food options with the owners/family there as chef, host and hostess overseeing all. BYOB as well
-
February 2024 by Paulette Drogon
Food was good,large portionsAt first, the service was great.The place filled up due to their anniversary event. At that time, you could not get timely service.Other things that happened were a little annoying.The owner was wonderful and very welcoming.
-
February 2024 by DavidB
I was happy to see that the dining room was full on a Saturday evening. Good for the restaurant. It was noisy but I could have an easy conversation with my guest. Service was reasonably attentive but we were provided dessert menus after appetizers and before our entrees were served. Perhaps that error was due to the fact that staff waits on multiple tables. We were on table 25. I/we have dined previously at La Pergola. The interior is a beautiful color, particularly in daylight. I would/will dine there again.
-
February 2024 by Kathy Guarino
Great variety of delicious Italian food, fresh fish dishes snd wonderful staff and owner.
-
February 2024 by kathyg
Great service, pretty atmosphere and delicious food. Had a table by the window for a Saturday lunch and everything we ordered was delicious! We recommend the figs, tuna and squash soup. The almond cake and cappuccino topped off a fantastic 3 course meal
-
February 2024 by
Five of us surprised my aunt with dinner. First time here. Everyone loved it. Still getting people making comments on how good the food and service was days later. Highly recommend.
-
February 2024 by Mary Grace Lattig
Pre- theater dinner, very accommodating, good food, a BYO and atmosphere.
-
January 2024 by Y H
stay away! forced tipping!
-
January 2024 by MaryP
LaPergola is our go to for dinner in Millburn. The food is consistently delicious and the wait staff is friendly and attentive. We shared the artichoke and stuffed mushrooms and then we had Eggplant Lasagna and the PorkChop special. Awesome!!
-
January 2024 by
Excellent experience, one of many returns. The chef altered a menu item to my preference. As usual we were in our Papermill seats on time. Service impeccable and attentive. Quiet intimate ambiance. A go to before the theater. Always a 5 Star meal where you are treated like royalty
-
January 2024 by WilliamL
Maitre d' , wait staff and support staff all knowledgeable and attentive. Regular menu enhanced by great specials. Food prepared as requested, delivered hot and all appetizers and meals, 4 diners, were delicious.
-
December 2023 by DavidM
Food is overpriced for what you get. Staff is unfriendly and unwelcoming. The restaurant looks much nicer in photos but really it's just one big room with tables next to each other. This does not allow for much room, and the noise level is absurd. Do not recommend you spend your time and money here.
-
December 2023 by
The quality of the food and service were excellent. Parking was a little difficult but most was due to the Paper Mill having a performance that night. It was a little noisy. Overall our experience was very satisfactory.
-
December 2023 by RichS
Food was excellent and service was attentive and cordial. First time at this restaurant and I was very impressed with the food quality and presentation. I highly recommend their pounded chicken parmigiana, Mahi Mahi and rack of lamb. Seating at a four top was a little tight but I understand the need to make best use of the space. Overall, quite good and I will happily return.
