Thomas Sweet Ice Cream is a popular dessert spot in a college town, known for its delicious ice cream and milkshakes. Customers enjoy the friendly staff and the good quality of the treats. The milkshakes are especially praised for their taste, though some find the extra charges for toppings surprising and note that thin straws can make it hard to enjoy thick drinks. The ambiance is small and sometimes appears rushed, with some customers mentioning that the place looks dirty and in need of cleaning. Waffles are also available, but some find them stale. Overall, the business is appreciated for its tasty offerings and friendly employees, but improvements in cleanliness and atmosphere could enhance the experience.
Located on the main drag of New Brunswick business and Rutgers. Walked down the block after dinner. Satisfied my desire for a sweet treat. 9.8/10
March 2026
Best ice cream ever - full stop. Loyal fan since 1986 when I was a student at RU. In photo is cookies & cream with mint and heath bar blend in. Magical.
March 2026
Alice and Franny were spectacular humans today. Super sweet, patient with my grandmother and I. Empathetic, explanatory and really connective. I'm grateful we went
