Meat Shops near New Milford, NJ

30 locations found near New Milford
View Map

“Delicious, quality meat selection! The owner and other guy working there were very helpful and even suggested recipe tips for cooking the specific meat I bought. They were definitely knowledgeable. I’ll definitely be going back!”

4.6 Superb49 Reviews

“I love this market. It has very authentic natural herb and food products.I get all lind of honey and tea, oils for cooking and meats. I very much recommend it. The prices are reasonable.”

4.9 Superb72 Reviews

“Locally sourced food is the way to go these days and Goggle Farms is amazing. The staff was patient for this newbie to the store and explained how to make the wait shorter on the weekend. But the difference in taste for the chicken and eggs purchased is amazing.”

4.8 Superb76 Reviews

“Love this place if you know then you know everything here is the best and closest salumeria to being in Italy as it gets only the best when I'm in the bronx god bless”

4.7 Superb119 Reviews

“The Arthur Avenue Retail Market is one of several public food halls across the city, including Essex Market (LES), Jamaica Farmers Market (Queens), La Marqueta (Harlem), and the Moore Street Market (Brooklyn).The Arthur Avenue market opened in 1940 to serve the predominantly Italian neighborhood and still does to this day.There are several vendors, including butchers, fresh produce sellers, dry goods, and at least one restaurant and sandwich joint.I was running errands in the area and needed a sandwich, so I ordered a mortadella and broccoli raab sandwich from Mike's in the back on the right. They also offer many pre-made sandwiches if you are in a rush, but I like to order off the menu.The butchers look great and have an assortment of specialties, including offal and fresh rabbits. I can't wait to see what they offer around Easter time.There are a few tables near the bar in the back and as part of the restaurant, but it's hard to say if you are welcome to sit there to eat a sandwich. Regardless, it's a great spot to check out if you are walking along and want to pop into NYC, equivalent to a European food hall.”

4.8 Superb56 Reviews

“Been going to B&M for many years! Always fresh and always delicious. Jonathan and his staff are friendly and the food is consistently amazing! We loved their prepared meals as well as their holiday menus and meats (steaks, burgers, sausage, and hot dogs)”

4.7 Superb36 Reviews

“The best super market with in the area. Always has the best and freshest meat and chicken. Also have a wide selection of international foods. You will literally find anything you are looking for here. Staff are extremely friendly and willing to do whatever it takes to make sure their customers are satisfied. Owner has even offered to get me a ride home because my husband was taking too long to pick me up! If that doesn’t scream great customer service i don’t know what does! The owner and the arab butcher specifically are super friendly and always trying to put a smile on their customers faces by having funny conversations. Owner is always in the store which shows how much they care about their business. Could not recommend this store enough!”

4.6 Superb31 Reviews

“The absolute best home made pork provisions in North Jersey. It’s like a candy store for adults. Everything is absolutely high quality. The landjäger is delicious. Teewurst is a must try. They make some every Thursday. The fresh made veal loaf is top notch. The counter guys are fast and efficient. I highly recommend this place.”

4.6 Superb31 Reviews

“I went today for the first time to buy goat meat and let me tell you this place didn’t disappoint. The owner/butcher was super friendly and helpful. The prices are excellent/reasonable. I’m shocked that this place doesn’t have a 5 star rating. I highly recommend this place because I for sure will be coming back!”

4.7 Superb23 Reviews

“Very good meat, all kinds of sausages from their production. The cheese meatballs are amazing. A little hot, but great.Excellent meat quality and service!Good selection of canned and pickled vegetables.”

4.8 Superb17 Reviews

“Finding a good hot dog/sausage is much harder than you would think. This place is a good solution for that. It's a little stand outside of a butcher shop. There is a line basically all of the time. Is it earth shattering? No. But if you want a brat and want it grilled up nicely, this is your place. Kielbasa is $10. It's huge, pretty good but skip it for something else like the brat. The brat is $4. Worth it.”

4.8 Superb16 Reviews

“Loved the attention! Meats are fresh. Products are consistently replenished. Customer service is poppin, the people who work here are very hospitable and welcoming. Prices are awesome- super reasonable considering inflation. Even the cashier was sweet and informative!”

4.7 Superb18 Reviews

“The best Italian Deli ever!You can find very unique gourmet cheeses at reasonable prices. Full bakery, wine shop, all kinds of Italian specialty products.Love the vibe and of course the food!”

4.3 Superb75 Reviews

“Some of best fresh perogies around, tender pasta and creamy potatoe filling. Wait for kielbasa and deli is long because everything is sliced on the spot, but worth the time. The locals / staff all order in polish which can be daunting but english translation below each label. It also helps that the checkout employees speak English. While waiting, don't forget the chocolate selection on the side.”

4.4 Superb34 Reviews

“Def a 5 star company!! From customer service to quality of meats they are hard to beat ! I have been to many meat markets and mbh is def my first choice won’t disappoint!!”

4.6 Superb18 Reviews

“Dennis and Julia were very kind in trying to help me resolve and issue that turned out to be my fault. Superb customer service and great steaks and burgers as always!!!”

4.6 Superb18 Reviews

“If you're polish you will find everything you may need here - just like back home. Including some cosmetics, magazines and medicines. Selection is huge for a pretty small place. Meats, cheeses and cold cuts are top quality. They also have hot food which is way better than in most Polish restaurants in the area. Selection includes soups and desserts. Perfect place to get your polish supplies or to experience Polish homemade food.”

4.6 Superb17 Reviews

“Best halal meat store that Ma.sha.Allah provide HMS sharia board approved meat & chicken, very clean and nice store with lot of Groceries, owner Javed bhai such a nice man , highly Recommended .”

5 Superb9 Reviews

“Ordered thanksgiving turkey and all the trimmings to makes things easier this year…everything was outstanding…definitely a good deal… saved us a lot of cooking time with out missing out on the homemade tastes”

4.7 Superb13 Reviews

“I love your five and dime brewery. Sal, great job on your new restaurant. Looks very nice your new area I like you new dining room and your new restaurant. Very good job. Sal your new restaurant”

4.3 Superb35 Reviews

“Excellent. Last week I had 3 platters prepared from Glatt Express for my family chanukah party. They were all beautiful and fresh and delicious. I came back today to shop - they had all the products I needed at decent prices. Thank you Glatt Express!”

4.2 Good67 Reviews

“If you have any memories of Hungarian cuisine from your childhood or from trips, you could be entertained here with all the important ingredients and ready made delicacies in surprisingly reach varieties compared to the size of the store. The sausages, the salamis, cold cuts and even their bakery products are impeccable. My rating is, no question, 5*.”

4.8 Superb10 Reviews

“Casablanca is Excellent when it comes to Fresh Meat to.Order God Bless Casablanca for Being in business for so long I have been shopping there since 1980 .........The Meat is Fresh ...Well Known for being the Best Butcher East to West”

4.4 Superb21 Reviews

“Been going there for more than a decade. Great meats with excellent service. Prices are more expensive thank supermarket prices, but meat quality is much much better. Highly recommend them.”

4.9 Superb8 Reviews

“Yo, you guys talkin bout me? I no your not talkin about me. Watch out these guys are tough. And, all of that tradition go's into the making of a Fine Italian Product.”

5 Superb7 Reviews

“Bigger market than others and more options on international foods. Still have kosher options as well. Prices are also typically better than other bigger corporate markets.”

4.1 Good138 Reviews

“There are a few butcher shops on authur ave but for me this is my favorite. This place will literally do whatever you want them to do to a cut of meat. They also carry things like duck, lamb, rabbit, quail, and a few other more exotic meats if you're into that kind of stuff. Great place and make sure you ask for Jimmy he is a true professional!”

4.2 Good43 Reviews

“Fresh halal meat and that makes it taste delicious.Best price in town.The owner is very honest that I order what I want over the phone and pick it up later.I go there for beef and chicken but they have variety of middle eastern food as well.Great service.”

4.3 Superb19 Reviews

“I have tried out 4 different halal meat markets in North Jersey and this is by far the best! Big store, clean, neat, and organized. The customer service is amazing and the meat is fresh and great quality. Butchers are busy in the back, so you can tell the meat is good. They even have halal cold cuts! Everything is very pristine. Will be shopping here again!”

4.1 Good59 Reviews

“This is the ONLY place I will travel to for some baby turkey wings . They are always super courteous and polite. Best meat market. Oh and the Cooked food that they chef up is Good too .”

4.7 Superb7 Reviews