Banks near Old Tappan, NJ

30 locations found near Old Tappan

“The Old Tappan branch of Bank of America in Old Tappan is exceptional. The staff is highly competent, professional, and consistently friendly. I always know I can depend on this team to help me with my banking needs.”

4.6 Superb14 Reviews

“I have been using Kearny bank since 1993, they were used to call South Bergen back in the days . But service is top notch.. Highly recommended for small business owners to set up their accounts, especially if you’re interested to get better benefits through your account!!”

3.7 Good6 Reviews

“Mr John,Reed gave an amazing costumer service.He was kind, understanding and very helpful.I got there when the bank just closed and he still helped me.Thank you Mr John !!!”

5 Superb108 Reviews

“I had a great meeting and I opened an account with Chetan in Nyack branch the bank is awesome. They provide a lot of good accounts and opportunities for homeowners people who want to save and invest. They are the best Trustco Bank Number one.”

4.9 Superb39 Reviews

“Rafael, has been very helpful and knowledgeable with bank account to open up. He always looks out for the customers best interest. Thank you for all the information and help!”

5 Superb31 Reviews

“I have been a loyal customer for an extended period. The consistent excellence in customer service, coupled with the readily available products and promotions, has consistently provided a superior personal banking experience.”

4.9 Superb50 Reviews

“The employees here are very helpful and friendly. For years my boyfriend and I have worked with Geri, and most recently with Jyoti, for banking/investing. They explain options well and seem to genuinely care about you and your finances. We highly recommend this branch in Dumont.”

4.9 Superb33 Reviews

“Amazing branch very nice welcoming Alexandra from the loan department very nice and explains everything and Pilar from member service also extremely nice helpful and very informative.”

4.4 Superb126 Reviews

“I had a very good conversation with Diana Lopez. She helped me set up my account online and answered my questions with confidence and compassion and very patient with me”

4.4 Superb119 Reviews

“Mike was a 5 star banker for this experience. I have been recommending him to all my friends and family for their mortgage needs. Cannot rate him highly enough ! He made this process very easy for me !”

4.8 Superb22 Reviews

“Amazing experience went here to open an Account and experience was nothing but amazing all of the staff are very kind and helpful looking forward to having a great banking future with affinity ! Would highly recommend this CU to everyone in rockland and NJ”

4.9 Superb20 Reviews

“I have been at Foundry bank for several years and them. Totally impressed with ELISE. She should be commended for her knowledge, client service and friendliness to all the customers. I highly recommend Elise and this bank For all your banking needs.”

4.9 Superb22 Reviews

“I had such a great experience working with Enock Brutus at the Orangeburg office. He was so responsive and helpful - making my transaction go so smoothly. I was so thankful that he was able to meet my tight deadline so that I could get the vehicle that I wanted. Thank you!”

5 Superb18 Reviews

“A wonderful experience. An incredible atmosphere with a highly trained and friendly staff; especially Mrs. Mercedes and Mrs. Bunny. They are the best, they explain everything very well and are very kind. Highly recommended.”

4.5 Superb32 Reviews

“Not a member, just needed something notarized.Called, spoke to a person, came in, got my notarization. Easy process and nice employees.I do not have a relationship with this bank but will consider it for the future based on my interaction with them. Thanks Steve!”

4.7 Superb20 Reviews

“We’ve been banking with Orange Bank & Trust Company for several years, and the experience has been consistently exceptional. The Middletown Road branch consistently delivers outstanding customer service, and the team is always friendly, responsive, and willing to go the extra mile. In particular, AS-Branch Service Manager, Michelle Piscani has been a tremendous resource—always ready to help, answer questions, and provide support whenever needed. Her professionalism and genuine care make a real difference. We truly appreciate the level of service OBT provides and find them to be a true business partner with our business.”

5 Superb12 Reviews

“I had to renew a CD this afternoon. Ian, the brand new employee and the other seasoned employee were all consummate professionals with the utmost competence and friendliness.”

4.9 Superb22 Reviews

“First time visiting this place and got to say it was a great experience. They had to take a few extra measures to authentic me which can be a bit annoying but hey they are very nice and get the job done. Will absolutely return.”

4.7 Superb19 Reviews

“I was so unhappy with Apple Bank until I found Miriam Aidoo at the New City Branch. I travel alot and personal customer service is important to me. I am so grateful to have Miriam to work with.”

4.4 Superb20 Reviews

“We spent more than two hours with Dudley Albert at the Teaneck office. . The professional service, personal care and patient explanation were exemplary. Thank you so much.”

4.7 Superb15 Reviews

“Very professional staff very welcoming and supportive personnel. I always come to this brunch for any help or questions. Strongly recommend the people of Spencer Saving bank at Elmwood Park.
Zeev Sela”

4.2 Good20 Reviews

“The airmont staff is the best. They have provided support when needed the most and are a very reliable bank to work with. Much better experience than dealing with a large corporate branches.”

4.2 Good21 Reviews

“Had a recent HELOC application and closing with Ellen Brooks. She made the process very easy with clear communication and quick response to all of our questions. Highly recommend Palisade credit union as well as the New City Branch.”

4.2 Good22 Reviews

“The entire staff is lovely.
Julia and Nelly always very helpful and friendly.
Front girls Mariafe, Walquiria and of course Marija Durovic always provide best possible service.
Very satisfied with this team.”

4.1 Good27 Reviews

“You’re treated with respect and no wait time. Very concerned to make sure your account is safe. They check your identity throughly to make sure it’s you. Very professional and pleasant.”

4.4 Superb27 Reviews

“Good customer service. I usually don't have to wait very long in line here, sometimes its a little long but they are very efficient. The tellers and staff are helpful. I really like that this bank is in a very safe neighborhood.”

4.3 Superb28 Reviews

“Juat wanted to leave a review Elizabeth. She went above and beyond and exceed my expectations. My bank card was having issues on Friday after business hours. And I had to come in the next day, which I wasnt happy about. I explained to Elizabeth the situation and informed me nothing couldn't really be done due the weekend but she did the impossible. She called a few ppl and my card started working later that Saturday evening...thank you soo much Elizabeth for making the impossible possible”

4.6 Superb27 Reviews

“Exceptional service each and every time. Today Shereen helped me and she was kind, professional, knowledgeable, and efficient. Interactions like this put a smile on my face.”

4.5 Superb14 Reviews

“I had an outstanding experience at the Flagstar Bank branch on Thursday, August 21, 2025.
Maria Castro and her team went above and beyond, providing truly white-glove service. Maria was warm, attentive, and an absolute pleasure to deal with. She made it clear that she’s not just here to provide banking services — she’s here to help our business grow. It’s rare to find customer service that feels both personal and professional, and this team delivered exactly that. I gladly give Maria a 5-star rating for her exceptional service. Thank you for making the experience so pleasant!”

4.2 Good19 Reviews