Forest Dairy Deli & Liquor is a local convenience store and deli that has been serving the community for years. The reviews paint a mixed picture of the establishment, with both positive and negative experiences reported by customers.
On the positive side, many customers praise the quality of the sandwiches, describing them as delicious and fresh. The store is described as cute and convenient, with a good selection of both food and non-alcoholic and alcoholic beverages. Several customers recommend trying out the deli and note that the prices are fair.
However, there are also some areas for improvement. Some customers have experienced issues with the accuracy of their food orders, with one reviewer noting that their breakfast sandwiches were "lean on content." Additionally, there have been concerns raised about the handling of food by the deli staff, with reports of employees not changing their gloves after handling items in the back of the store, which is described as "unbelievably disgusting."
Overall, Forest Dairy Deli & Liquor seems to be a mixed bag, with a loyal customer base that appreciates the convenience and quality of the sandwiches, but also some room for improvement in terms of order accuracy and food handling practices.
Friendly employee great sandwiches and delicious salad .
April 2026
Great experience at Forest Dairy Deli & Liquor! Clean store, wide selection, and very friendly staff. Super convenient one-stop shop—highly recommended 👍
March 2026
Best deli in all of Rutherford. 10/10 would come every time.
