-
February 2024 by Fluffalicious Morgan
Today January 26th 2023 I went to this shop prior to that Steve and I were communicating thru text pictures of the item for sale and all I traveled from East Orange to Rutherford to be told he wasn't interested in the item and don't like how it look however he received pics the day before and said yes he was can help me out and also purchase the item I had which was appraised @$400 he weighed it and said it can be worth $450 but didn't trust it his professionalism ,attitude etc.. was off even though I was referred by another appraiser who only buy coins I will never go here for business again
-
December 2023 by Richard Merkle
For those who say he has lost his touch; your wrong. This man is knowledgeable and has a respectable swagger. Much appreciated ? see ya later brother.-Rick
-
January 2023 by Adam Crosson
Great place for Coins , Pokemon, and sports cards. Steve is a guy with a lot of knowledge of the 3 main products he sells. I’ve never gone there for coins but that’s what the majority of his business is I would think. Myself I don’t do Pokémon but I’m big into sports cards. Steve has a huge selection of sports card singles and prices that won’t break your wallet. But my surprise came when I walked in and saw all of the wax mostly retail baseball nba and nfl. But he has boxes that are from last year as well as the most recent boxes that have hit the stores and you can’t find anywhere. Not bad prices considering where he’s located it’s almost impossible to buy sone of the boxes at that price without driving 25 miles to match his price. I almost didn’t want to write a review because i was nervous my secret would get out about Steve’s Coin shop not only having coins, that the boxes will all be gone. But im writing this because Steve and his over 30 year old shop is a diamond in the no sports cards rough. So I would recommend this shop 10/10 times and I’d travel up to a hour to get to Steve’s.Keep up the good work Steve and hide some boxes for me because if people read this I don’t think you’ll have any left!Thanks SteveAdam Crosson
-
January 2023 by J J
"I don't show these to people, they're a lot of money" is what I'm told when asked to see the rare pokemon cards. This place is a joke. Everything is over priced and the guy is totally rude. I will never go back and would highly recommend everyone to STAY AWAY. Find Pokemon packs for half the price anywhere else in town.
-
December 2022 by Geo Amps
Steve has always been honest and fair with his appraisals and sales.His store and collection is very impressive!
-
September 2022 by Jared C
Very friendly and informative when my wife and I stopped in. Great little store with a ton of stuff in it. Coins sports cards etc.
-
September 2022 by Alexander Alvarez
He’ll give the worst possible value for your coins period, and will not be honest with you.
-
April 2022 by Thomas DePascale
Had a very good experience with Steve. Strictly coins so I have no idea about the cards and other things, but he knows his coins and is fair and reasonable in pricing. Going into a shop for coins you must realize that he/she must make a profit to stay in business, so for those of you who want to get something for nothing buy from ebay and hope you get something good. For me I would rather deal direct from a store or at a coin show where I can see what it is that I am spending my money on.
-
March 2022 by Ethan Goya
Worst place ever!Over priced items and is very rude.Steve did not help and threw the cards at you.DO NOT RECOMMEND
-
October 2021 by Alex Singleton
Doesn’t know how to talk to people, must’ve had the shop inherited or not making money like he used to. Instead of getting angry at random customers use the energy to maybe idk adjust to the times? Just a grumpy old man who fell off.
-
September 2021 by Kinga Wikii-wikii
Screw Steve! I waited outside the of his business 7 minutes after he was supposed to be opened. He then made us wait until he turned off his alarm system. We walked into an 80 degree setting so I was already in a rush to get my son one pack of Pokemon cards. My son was browsing, asking me which ones he could get, Steve interjects and says, "pick whichever one you want kid". So he does, picks one pack and goes up to the counter. I said I'm paying with credit card and he replied, "that's it?" I said yes and he immediately refused to sell the pack because he doesn't get the money back from a credit transaction until two days, so it's just not worth the trouble. I was so confused but didn't even bother going back and forth, I was actually happy to get out of that sauna. Upon exiting, another customer said to him, "it's 100% your choice but do you really think it's not worth the sale?" He proceeded to explain himself but again, I was already out the door. I got in my car and called him to let him know how unprofessional he was. His response was, "thousands of people pay me with cash and give me no trouble" and then hung up. SCREW STEVE! End rant.
-
September 2021 by Tom Linker
Unless you want spend 2-3x MSRP for barely desirable sets of cards, don’t come here. You’ll waste your time.
-
November 2020 by Joseph Seborowski
Great place
-
September 2020 by Alex S
steve is unwelcoming seems to hate his job
-
April 2019 by Brian D.
Steve is a very personable and friendly collector and dealer of popular collectibles .( noted in his business name-), who has an area of all years and conditions of all kinds of cards,coins and stamps. I've done a few deals with him and he is an honest and fair guy! I highly recommend and would do business with him again! I don't live in his area but my cousins do I visited and then have done dealings with Steve through Facebook thereafter! You should check out all the goods he has if your in the area! .
