Stutz Candy Company is the best candy store on the island, with five generations of making candy the old-fashioned way. The inside is filled with walls and racks of treats, offering a great selection from sugar free, dark, and milk chocolates to salt water taffy, fudge, gummy candy, and all-time childhood favorites. They have so much more than expected, including pecan clusters, chocolate covered pretzels, milk chocolate vanilla caramels, and raspberry filled milk chocolate. There is also a little bakery upstairs with yummy cupcakes and a small assortment of souvenirs. The shop is nice and clean, and the staff are friendly, inviting, and super friendly. It is the place to go to satisfy chocolate and sugar cravings. Order online or visit their stores to purchase.
Pretty good selection of chocolates and candies. If I'm in the area, I will definitely stop in again. The ladies were super helpful and pleasant to chat with.
July 2026
Only place that has Licorice & mollasses & mint salt water taffy!!!
July 2026
Very nice people working there. Delicious candies too.
