Black Horse Cigar Shop offers a great selection of cigars at fair prices. The owners are helpful and knowledgeable, often smoking cigars themselves. Customers praise the shop's spacious lounge and wide range of cigar accessories. While some cigars may be drier than others, the majority of the selection is well-humidified. Overall, Black Horse Cigar Shop is a popular spot for cigar enthusiasts, known for its accommodating staff and convenient location.