-
March 2024 by CarmenO
We went to eat here yesterday, Friday the 15th for lunch and it was very nice. People were friendly onion soup was delicious and my husband's sandwich for the day. It was delicious as well.
-
March 2024 by Traveler
The service was the standout, the server was wonderful and her assistant never let the water glass get to half empty. We both had specials offered for the evening Scallops for my wife, coffee rubbed ribeye for me. Both were excellent and huge, the Irish cream cheesecake was also outstanding.
-
February 2024 by Tony
It was easy to make a reservation. The food was good. The service was excellent. My wife ordered your banana bread pudding for desert and was told there wasn't any. We will visit you again. Thank you. Anthony J. Delaglio
-
February 2024 by KarenB
The Smithville Inn never disappoints. The menu has something for everyone and is always cooked to perfection with beautiful presentation. Our server was attentive and personable. The Inn rewards program is an extra perk too!
-
February 2024 by DebraL
Meal was fabulous and very lucky to have the private room for an 80th Birthday. However the best part of the night was our server Tricia. She was outstanding dealing with a large party and the kids. She made the experience so much more. Thank you for a great night!
-
February 2024 by SarahS
Amazing- from Mike the valet to the front desk welcome- Dom our waiter was attentive and kind, the manager checked on us. This was such a lovely place- the seafood bouillabaisse was outstanding and the filet Oscar mouth watering !!! Atmosphere great- piano was live in the background. My friend and I felt like we were transported to a hallmark card!!! And the cheesecake- get it! Even the americano and cappuccino were well made! Thanks smithville Inn- I recommend and commend you!
-
February 2024 by OCDeb
I've been coming here a very long time. I love the traditional feel, the consistent quality of food and service and the historic element. I am not a fan of fast food nor technology. Last two times the waitresses have had to use a digital hand held order device. That's a complete turn off! It's hard to put in special requests, I have no desire to have it placed on the table nor touch it. It takes away from the dinning experience And is unsanitary!!!!! I want a paper receipt, I don't want stupid computers at my table or handed to me. I don't want to be told what to tip. When I told manager about my dislike of this device she said oh you can request it done the other way. Not true!!! The waters are told they must use these horrible, ugly, not appropriate devices. I love Smithville. I love old world charm, why do new managers come in and right away think to fix something that's not broken. Shame. Just a real shame
-
February 2024 by Rachael
Always an excellent meal. From the time we alked in, the hosetess was on top of things, our waitress was top notch, the expaditer didn't have knowledge of the menu. The bar tender didn't have a creative side but made the drink specials. Overall it was great.
-
February 2024 by
We had lunch and the special were great. The filet medallions were tender. The French onion soup delicious. The truffle fries tasted fantastic. We will be back maybe dinner next time.
-
February 2024 by
We've eaten here several times and have had positive experiences. They were not terribly busy this particular evening. We ordered a couple of drinks, couple bowls of soup and an appetizer to start in addition to our two entrees. The bowls of soup came out with the wrong appetizer, then the correct one came out later. Just a few minutes into the soup being (no exaggeration) out and even less time with the appetizer, our two entrees came out. Then the waitress came over and asked if that was okay, and mentioned they weren't supposed to come out. We felt weird about it and didn't want the food to be waiting in the kitchen and just agreed to have it stay out. We ended up barely touching the appetizer and by the time we finished the soup our entrees were cold. Also, a complimentary salad was supposed to come with the one entree, which never did and was never mentioned. The restaurant isn't cheap, and again was not very busy outside of an event they had going on that evening. Disappointing experience for the price.
-
February 2024 by JackS
The chicken pot pie is outstanding: beautifully presented and very tasty; the crab cake was good, but overpriced; the sirloin dip was flavorful, but a bit tough; the fish tacos were OK. $5 for a CUP of corn chowder? $4 for a glass of milk (that's more than I paid for a 1/2 gallon) and $3.25 for a cup of tea (that's one tea bag and hot water) are outrageous! Also, $14 for a Manhattan is NYC prices!! We did have a leisurely 2 hour lunch (1-3); it was quiet and the waitress was excellent. The entrance foyer was beautifully decorated for Valentine's Day and the wood fire in the 18th c. walk-in fireplace contributed to a welcoming, cozy ambience. We will return--but probably stick to water.
-
February 2024 by FrancesA
Our experience was lovely. The Inn was beautifully decorated for Valentine's Day. We enjoyed the delicious 3 course dinner for $35. The food was excellent and the desserts yummy!
-
February 2024 by ChemGirl
The Smithville Inn has always had an upscale romantic ambience. The special February decor enhanced this feel. We were pleasantly surprised by the wide selection of special Valentine menu entrees. Everything was delicious and portions were large. I recommend Smithville for any special occasion - especially Valentine's Day!
-
February 2024 by NnnnH
Excellent dinner, the food was delicious as usual. I had the salmon, one of the best restaurants to order it from, they make it amazing, my husband had surf and turf that he absolutely loved. Morgan our server was fantastic, attentive and quick! We love to eat here!!
-
February 2024 by
Went for the Prime Rib special. Had a drink at the bar first, Hank was great. Went to the table, waitress seemed annoyed. Brought water, we were ready to order, she wasn't. Came back to take drink order and we were ready to order, she was not. Came back with drinks and took the order. Food came out timely and was delicious. Seasoned and cooked perfectly. Green beans and potatoes were great as well as the Yorkshire pudding. Waitress became friendly when she dropped off the check. No follow up or drink refill. $35 pp was a great value for serving size.
