-
March 2024 by Joseph DeMichele
We just sold our card collection to Just Collect, Inc. John Palomares made the process so easy and delivered a high level of customer service. He gave us an estimated appraisal prior to shipping the cards, paid to ship the collection with added insurance, and emailed a final review payment offer! I would highly recommend this company for anyone looking to sell their collections.
-
March 2024 by Michael Strelzik
I stopped by the new Just Collect location in Summit. I had a great time talking about the vintage cardboard and the silly twists and turns of the beloved game of baseball. I had the opportunity to discuss the Vintage Break process with John and the growing business with other delightful members of the Just Collect staff. In my interactions with the team, it became very apparent how knowledgeable the group is with all things sports cards collecting. The team offers fair pricing for both buyers and sellers and will go the extra mile to ensure their customers return, as I will be. Keep it up Just Collect!
-
February 2024 by Matteo Sicignano
This is the worst card shop ever I came wanting to grade my card’s because it said it was open but then when we tried to find the store we could not find it then we tried calling no answer this is horrible
-
February 2024 by Hunter Smutney
Had a great experience with Just Collect. They were fair on their pricing and kept to their word of paying the same day they received the card in the mail. Would definitely recommend if you're looking to sell sports memorabilia.
-
October 2023 by khumia buchanon
Love the atmosphere. They gave me a very fair price for my cards and did not try to low ball me.. I’ll definitely be back to sell more.
-
October 2023 by Emilio Schmidt
Pricey with a decent collection. Feel that they should display more with all the space they have. Their eBay store is great though
-
September 2023 by Doug Ferguson
Got a fair deal with my O-Pee-Chee Gretzky rookie card. It came back from the appraiser rated a 6. Thought it would be higher, maybe a 7 or an 8.Y'all be the judge
-
September 2023 by Bill Kelly
Leighton and his professional, courteous staff are well worth your consideration when choosing to sell your collectible treasures.
-
September 2023 by Michael Niestempski
Very Professional and Honest...Very Helpful and transparent they went above and beyond from day 1 of meeting them ..Thank You and hope to do business again in the future.
-
August 2023 by Mike Harrigan
I just sold my complete set of 1957 Topps football cards which included Starr, Unitas, and Hornung rookie cards. This is my first venture selling more than one card at a time and was very pleased with the consideration I was given--I was treated as a valuable customer with great respect. I collected the vast majority of this set as a kid many years ago, and then filled in the cards I was missing to complete the set.Working with John was a pleasure and I was treated very well--timeliness, very willing to work with me on the prices, and the advice he provided was very helpful. It was strange just sending my cards to John (which they paid for) with only his word via emails and phone. He kept me apprised of the process and progress and we finalized the deal today, just as he promised--I expect to receive the check later this week.Thanks to John and Just Collect for being very professional and fair. I am a very happy customer and won't hesitate to work with them again.
-
August 2023 by Richard Corpening
Selling all or even a part of your prized collection is a difficult choice. I talked to several potential buyers before settling on John Palomares at Just Collect. I opted to sell only a small part of my collection simply because that’s what I’m comfortable doing at this time. Perhaps in the future I’ll sell more or even all of my collection. What appealed to me most about Just Collect was the fact I could send them cards I was interested in selling—at their expense (and insured), allowing them to offer a maximum price, i.e. they saw exactly what was for sale. Clearly this requires trust on my part but John stayed in close communication with me and I was very confident and trusted their process. Meanwhile I did some homework assessing what the cards I sent to them were bringing in current market venues, e.g. eBay, etc. I felt the initial offer from Just Collect was quite fair with the exception of a couple of sets. We had a couple of subsequent discussions regarding condition, etc. and came to an agreement on price that I was most satisfied with. I would strongly encourage anyone considering selling to consider Just Collect. I felt no pressure to sell but did feel confident in their knowledge and, most importantly, trusted them with my cards and their assessment. No regrets.
-
July 2023 by Josh R
Contacted them using their own website's "Appraisal Form," which states that it may take up to 48 hours to get back to you. I provided a detailed description of a large vintage card collection from my father that includes high value cards such as Mantle, Jackie Robinson, Ted Williams cards, Joe Di Maggio, et al. Two complete '48 Bowman sets, as well as valuable football, boxing, and other vintage cards (est. 700 or so) most in good to excellent condition. I received no reply. Not even, "thanks, but we are not interested."Called to follow up (after a month) and was told that if I didn't hear anything, they weren't interested. So much for 48 hours. Will take the collection elsewhere.
-
July 2023 by David Fiumara
Visited one of their open houses a few weeks ago. The guys are very knowledgeable and professional and know a lot about the industry. Look forward to going back in the future.
-
June 2023 by Kyle O'Kane
The process was very smooth sent the cards in for delivery and the day they received the cards sent me an offer. Highly recommended.
-
May 2023 by wayne sookraj
This is the best card dealer in all of nj and even ny gave me honest and fair pricing. The service is excellent and the staff is very helpful and pleasant. The pricing is very much in line with the industry and above other store's. Great service will recommend that you take your cards here.
