-
March 2025 by Peter Wagner
Amazing smells & kind staff. Full sour pickles, pickled tomatoes and marinated mushrooms are my go to.
-
March 2025 by Rafi Rothschild
Didnt answer their phones once last week. Horrible service
-
February 2025 by Chelsea Davis
Recently stopped by on a week day and got some great pickles and olives. Our favorite ended up being the Sweet Chili 🌶️. The young woman that helped me (I’m sad to say I forgot her name) was so friendly, patient, and informative.
I was pleasantly surprised to see they also sell a selection of chocolates, candies, and even honey. It makes the space feel like a boardwalk shop or farmers market.
We live in West NY but will be making another trip to the shop this weekend. That’s how much we love this shop’s selection!
-
October 2024 by Gina DiStasio
Just ordered a gallon of the Cerignola olives. They were delivered so quickly! They were also boxed so nice in a refrigerated bag and ice! The Olives are amazing!!!! My new place for ordering olives!!!
-
October 2024 by Rina N
I came there to tell them what an amazing business they had but forgot to leave this review until now. They have samples of all their amazing pickles and they are all so good. I love it! Pickled tomatoes are my favorite but they also have nice things like jams and sesame candies
-
August 2024 by Robert Chadwick
Always the best pickles and olives 🫒 I was disappointed you where not at the manahawkin beer festival hopefully you will be at the wine festival
-
July 2024 by Celeste Lee
Best pickles ever but why pickle shoppe?? It's PICKALICOUS!!!
-
July 2024 by harry szafranski
The freshest and most authentic sours I’ve ever had, Gus would be proud
The candy selection so nostalgic and enticing
The olive dips and tapenade best I’ve ever had
Pretty much everything at the salad bar is a must try, soooo good and unique
Worth the trip from anywhere
-
July 2024 by Josh Kirschenbaum
I don’t eat pickles like that, I mean sometimes but it ends up being that lonely jar in the back of the fridge. I ATE AN ENTIRE JAR OF HORSERADISH PICKLES IN ONLY A FEW DAYS!! I JUST STARTED STICKING A FORK RIGHT IN THE JAR!! I’M NOT EVEN ASHAMED!! THEY’RE DELICIOUS!! THEY’RE THE GREATEST THING THAT HAS EVER HAPPENED TO ME!! Kidding! But they’re really really good!
-
June 2024 by Janeann Barlow
Bought your pickles, Firecracker chips, in Allentown NJ little farm market. WOW!!!!! Fantastic had them on my burger tonight!!! Amazing good. Really hope you return again. The two young people in the both were also great. I have been searching for the perfect pickle and I believe I found it!!!!!
-
May 2024 by GARY MASS
Went to purchase pickels which I'm enjoying.Disappointed though with the high cost of the plain olives, as the container was $8 for 22 olives.
-
May 2024 by Veronica Dunscombe
Love their products. They are the very best and wonderful!!!!!
-
April 2024 by Patrick Skalski
Incredible horseradish pickles
-
April 2024 by Catherine Kerr
Best pickled goods and amazing, thoughtful customer service. We particularly love their jalapeño stuffed olives!
-
April 2024 by Rennie Jacob
Great staff and even tastier products
