Butter Me Up is a charming small business in Toms River that offers a delightful selection of gourmet butters, homemade scones, and clotted cream. Visitors often discover it by chance and are greeted with the heavenly aroma of baked scones. The shop features a huge variety of sweet and savory butters, with every product being delicious and unique. Many reviews mention the incredible flavors, such as Peach Fig Butter, orange vanilla, strawberry, and apple pie with clotted cream, which are perfect for snacking or recipes. The scones are praised for their perfect consistency and are available in different flavors, both sweet and savory. Customers appreciate the friendly owners who are thoughtful and kind, making each visit special. The shop is popular at the local farmers market, where new seasonal flavors are regularly introduced. Whether for gifts or personal indulgence, Butter Me Up is considered a hidden gem and a must-visit for those who love tasty, homemade treats.
Best grain pie and pizza rustica for the holidays. Can’t wait to order mine.
March 2026
This place is rockin' Scones, cookies, flavored butters, lemon curd, clotted cream - all home made & addictive. Run don't walk to this inventive bakery. You won't be disappointed. Your welcome!
March 2026
Great scones, great people. One of our favorite places in Toms River. Always leave with delicious butters and clotted cream as well (we love samples!). Look out for the monthly specials!
