“This place is a historical treasure. I have bought some very nice items from here. It's a pleasure going inside to shop, or even just driving by and imagining the history of the building.”
“Fairest of Them All is my favorite local shop. I always find something(s) I want each time I visit, and my loved ones know it's the go-to place for a gift that will make me smile.”
“I just love my art!! I went back and forth to her store a few times and finally said “Sold”
It looks great in our new home!
Thank you Cunningham’s, your store is the best!!”
Open 24 hours
2007 Long Beach Blvd Unit A, Long Beach
Gift Shops
“Drove by this shop and she was clearing out inventory and selling things for just $1 outside today. I picked through for a few things and when I paid she told me to take whatever else I saw for literally the $3 that I gave her. Such a sweet woman, I did grab two little candles she made and they smell wonderful!!
I love to support good people. Her energy was lovely & if I’m back in the area soon I’ll check out her soaps & other candles!”
“I travel an HOUR every time I need a gift. Was worried after they moved but i end up liking it just as much! If not more! The boat they are in is friggen awesome. Ecclectic selections. Something for everyone really. Love this store”
“GALLOWAY: Quirky and eclectic everyday decor, crafts, and seasonal items fill up this adorable store in Historic Smithville! They also have beautiful lawn signs for every occasion and you can't miss this shop and their beautiful outdoor display. Leashed dogs are allowed inside and be sure to use extra caution due to the delicate nature of the items and tight spaces to browse around.”
“Lots of inventory. Clothes, stuff for baby, gifts for women like candles and bath products, Brighton, whole room of Vera Bradley which isn’t my taste but obviously must be popular given the space allocated to it. They have gifts for men too. We will be back for gifts for sure.”
“For the past 10 years or more, I have enjoyed a weekend with my friends on LBI. Gifted by the Sea is our first stop for shopping. The store has a large variety of items for sale. I have never left this store empty handed. The clothes they sell are unique and top quality. Household items are nice, and the jewelry section is top notch. I recently purchased a garden ornament that is a heart made of blue sea glass. I have gotten so many compliments on how nice it looks in my front yard. The friendly and knowledgeable staff are always helpful when you need them. The checkout is fast and easy. There is literally something for everyone. I highly recommend the store and the staff!”
“Went here with my parents on Tuesday June 11th 2024 as part of our long beach vacation. We stopped at Historic Smithville to look at the shops there: this was one of them in which we brought something. They have lots of olive oils and vingarietes. Many of them one can sample, and we sampled one that tasted so good! the front desk person was very nice, and mixed some oils for us. she was also good at recommending items to pair with the oils. She also gave us a sheet with the website on it so that we can order more stuff anytime. My mom purchased some olive oil of the following: Italian Herb, blood orange, garlic, balasmic (2), and pineapple. Person at the front was indeed very nice. we paid via credit card. Highly recommend you check this place out!”
“Great little store in Smithville, very wide selection of honeys, the proprietor is extremely knowledgeable about her products. They have a good selection of local honeys. Great for my allergies. Enjoy every trip to this little gem.”
“i went to this shop a few days ago- i told the lady at the counter i’ve been having really bad dry skin (i work at a spa so i’m constantly washing hands between clients) and NOTHING helps. no matter what i use my hands are always dry.she recommended me bobbisue therapy. i tried it for the first time today.first picture was yesterday after work.second picture is today after work. i used this between clients.AMAZING!! will definitely be purchasing more.”
“I ordered an arrangement for my sister & brother-in-law’s anniversary. The shop called to let me know one of the fruits didn’t taste good so they were going to substitute it for something else and it was so nice that they did that. It’s not a cheap thing to get someone and you want to make sure the quality is there. Thank you for taking the time to check beforehand! They loved the arrangement!”
“My friend and I love our afternoon tea today at Lizzie’s Tea Room. Everything was delicious and the attention to detail was above and beyond. We will definitely be back!”