-
March 2024 by Tyler MM
This place had the best pizza I've ever had in my life at a great price too.
-
March 2024 by Tracey Lynn
Pizza One Rules!!!! Every single time!
-
March 2024 by Eglain Melendez
The managers here give great service! Even if the staff made a mistake on my order. The manager still made things right! Thats what you call excellent service! They do whatever it takes to satisfy there customers. Thank You Pizza 1 Haskell!
-
March 2024 by K
Most times the food is great there have been a few times it wasn't one time my penne was overcooked so now I ask for al dente just in case. This past Saturday the family ordered dinner and we ordered French fries and whoever took the order didn't hear it so when my brother went to pick it up there were no fries they offered to cook some but it would be a 15 min wait and the rest of our food would be cold plus another 15 min drive home so we did without.I wish the prices were comparable to the other restaurants around area they are more expensive so we usually stick to the Ringwood places and Pizza 1 is for special occasions. It's so expensive for a family of 4-5 people to get pasta dinners. A box of penne pasta cost $.98 at Walmart.
-
February 2024 by Keith Hascup
Good food, good prices. Get the pizza one fries!
-
February 2024 by Harrison Kanarick
Not traditional ny pizza in my opinion but still very good, especially the ones with the garlic knot crust. I’d go back.
-
February 2024 by S Turner
Love Pizza1! Killer sandwiches & creative yummy salads. Great portion sizes! My family loves the kickin' chicken every which way - on salad, sandwich or w/ side of broccoli sautéed in garlic - my fave. We've only had delivery past 4 yrs. Will have to stop by on a Friday to try the fun flavor combos. Keep up the great work!! Big fans here in Butler. Thank you to the whole crew ?? [we spend a little extra so we have good leftovers ?]
-
January 2024 by May Sanchez
Love this pizza!!! So good worth the drive which takes me approximately 30 minutes.
-
January 2024 by Victor Mani
Went in for a birthday party for a 3 year old and they allowed the kids to make their own pizza which is pretty neat. The food they made for the party itself was delicious especially the pizza.
-
January 2024 by Christine B
Great food.
-
January 2024 by Lorna Alberti
The food is delicious. The staff are polite and helpful. They catered a birthday party for us and every one of my guests raved about the great food.
-
December 2023 by Debbie Simonson
Always great food...
-
December 2023 by Peter Jan
Great little hometown pizza shop. Friendly folks and good pie. Nice side salad too, fresh.
-
November 2023 by Michael D'Agnilli
Pizza one is the best pizza in NJ, I will literally fight you if you disagree.Vegetarian options: Have multiple vegetarian optionsParking: Tight parking lot but can easily park on side streets.Kid-friendliness: Kids love pizzaWheelchair accessibility: Has a wheelchair ramp
-
November 2023 by Brian Reilly
Pizza was incredible. Had the pickle, chicken, garlic aioli, mozzarella, cheddar and hot honey slice, as well as buffalo chicken. They were cranking pizza out and had at least 10 people doing deliveries. Gave them all fives, four for atmosphere, I guess side room could be more interesting? Either way, highly recommend the pizza!