-
January 2026 by Peter
They are Very fair and Honest people I have dealt with Bonnie several times and Nick and way back with the two brothers they are all up front honest and always gave me the best deal possible. Thanks
-
November 2025 by P Carlisle
Bonnie knows her stuff. Very knowledgeable and honest.
-
November 2025 by Nick Morizzo
Expect 1/3 of melt for Canadian & foreign silver, even if it's Sterling. The two young guys are very unprofessional. I bought coins here years ago from the owner, the business has lost integrity. Dispite all the 5 star reviews, don't expect melt or anything close to it
-
November 2025 by Anthony Lugo
I visited several places to get quotes for some gold I wanted to sell, and Waretown Stamp and Coin was by far the best experience. The team was kind, honest, and never pushy. I truly felt they had my best interests at heart. I highly recommend them. Also, Bonnie was an absolute pleasure to work with!
-
November 2025 by Kevin Ellul
Always a pleasure to work with the staff! They’re great! They have many items for sale and are very helpful and knowledgeable is telling you the value or appraising your items!
-
November 2025 by Athena Polyviou
My husband and I recently sold some gold here and I have to say the level of service we received from Bonnie was top notch. Bonnie was super helpful and knowledgeable. We couldn’t have been more pleased with our experience here and will for sure be back!
-
October 2025 by Bradley Huston
5 stars every time. Staff is informative & fair on pricing.
-
September 2025 by Palmer Palmer
We had a great experience here. Rebecca and Bonnie are awesome and very knowledgeable. Prices are posted so you can know and understand what to expect. It was me and my mom and we sold some gold and sterling silver. With such great prices and great service we went back a week later with more jewelry. This is definitely our go to place now.
-
September 2025 by Carol Ann Donchin
Bonnie and Nick came to our home to help us appraise coins and jewelry. They were so helpful and fair. The entire process was seamless. Would highly recommend this company.
-
September 2025 by Jay Rosenbaum
Great business with great people
-
August 2025 by Jay Mathis
Jessie and I love Waretown Stamp and Coin. I have been going here since the 90's and Matt has always been fair and helpful. Now that Bonnie has been added to the staff, it is a truly amazing experience. I am looking forward to showing her my penny collection that her father helped me build. I need 4 more and it's complete. If you are a collector, this is the place to go. They have many beautiful pieces in most denominations. They have the best selection that I have seen in NJ, Pennsylvania or Delaware; and I've been to plenty of stores in the past 50 years. Visit them as soon as possible, it will definitely be worth your time. I'm going this Saturday, pennies in hand. Thank you Matt and Bonnie for all your help these past 30 years. I am looking forward to seeing you. Jay Mathis
-
August 2025 by David Lorenzini
I sold a bunch of jewelry and coins here.I felt very comfortable. With the people here they were not pushing and if I didn't want to sell , they said , no problem. A few pieces I sold later on. I wanted to piece of jewelry The price was lower than the week before, so she matched the price.She gave me the week earlier as a courtesy...
I never felt more comfortable then this place. I went to 15 places before this.staff is awesome..
-
July 2025 by Phillip Stone
Ok.. This place is amazing!!!!
Bonnie at Waretown Coin is one of the nicest, charismatic, and knowledgeable women in the numismatic business I've ever met! I've been in this hobby and collecting for over twenty years at this point; it's safe to say that it's seldom that you get the whole package when visiting a coin shop but Bonnie and Waretown Coin delivers!!
I was originally a customer of Waretown Coin about 3 to 5 years ago when they were in the same location just at the opposite end of their plaza. Now they've moved to the north side of the plaza into a much larger, nicer, well lit, well organized space.
Upon being buzzed in, you're first greeted by a very welcoming hello and then your senses are able to enjoy both great music and a jaw dropping amount of numismatic inventory in all directions!
Waretown Coin has pretty much everything:
Silver bullion
Gold bullion
Pre-'65 Silver
Pre-'33 Gold
Collectable old paper money
Slabbed/certified modern, old, and ancient coins
A bunch of album sets
Capitol holder sets
Modern US Mint coins in their gov't packaging
Comic books
Sports cards and even Pokemon cards
They also carry a ton of collectible supplies for sleeving, storing, and protecting your items.
They also sell beautiful jewelry, antiques, and random curious items that you have to come check out for yourself.
I came to the store today to purchase some constitutional silver which Bonnie had in great quantity.
While I was in the store, there must have been 5 to 10 people that came in after me and Bonnie assisted every single one of them and answered every one of their questions from start to finish in a very professional, pleasant manner.
Some of the people came in to just get quotes on their collections/metals/jewelery. Others came in to sell jewelry and some other people just wanted to purchase some coins and silver.
I just can't say how much I really enjoyed my trip to Waretown Coin and how I will be back as often as my wallet allows me lol.
Bonnie and everyone at Waretown Coin, thank you so much for running a great business.
Numismatics and a well-run coin shop are a welcoming safe haven for me and thanks to your business I can proudly say that I spent one of the best hours of my day in your store.
Take care.
-
April 2025 by Jake Bahooshian
Very knowledgeable
-
February 2025 by renee weiss
The best coin and stamp place around very attentive and knowledgeable employees here!! My husband and I feel at home at comfortable when we visit!!
