-
April 2024 by Mehmet Ali Kara
Good Service and very delicious selections.
-
March 2024 by Rosio B
What the heck happened to this place, I haven't been there in a while so I went there for a ham, salami and cheese sub...I literally got one sluce of ham and the same for salamy and cheese I basically paid $8 for a HSC flavored piece of bread...not going back.
-
December 2023 by John Cokley
I love this place!
-
October 2023 by SCOTT MENEGUS
VERY CLEAN. VERY FRIENDLY BILINGUAL STAFF. LARGE MENU VARIETY. ASK FOR THE CHEESESTEAK. GHO$T.
-
September 2023 by Diane Russell
I ordered a whole Ham and Swiss, I had one piece of ham rolled up with a lot of lettuce and tomato. Called to tell them that I will never order from them again!!!??
-
August 2023 by Michel'le Akman
Worst pizza. Crust and toppings were undercooked. We literally, and I kid you not, had to put the pizza back in the oven before eating and even after it was simply disgusting. Not authentic Italian whatsoever. Better off at Dominoes!
-
August 2023 by Anthony Poalillo
Place awesome great service
-
August 2023 by Laura Moreno
Pizza and Tony Soprano sub were delicious, great prices too.
-
June 2023 by tatyani lawton
I usually have good pizza but they were rude I wanted my pizza cooked better because it was not cooked all the way and they gave me a refund without telling me. All I asked was for it to be cooked alittle more and the weird Spanish guy had a whole problem for no reason. In his words make sure you ask for your pizza well done terrible service. I don’t have time to get sick
-
March 2023 by patrick postiglione
Best cheese steaks in West Orange! Pizza is delicious too. Very fast delivery. Very friendly. That didn't rate atmosphere because it's a small little pizzeria primarily for takeout and delivery.
-
January 2023 by Richard Nieves
Johnny's place is one of akind, I personally can't complain. Staffs are great people service on point, food is out of this world ?. It's place where families can enjoy themselves. ?
-
January 2023 by Nathan R.
To be honest, pizza taste is a personal thing. For me I like the old Brooklyn style pizza - thin crust, delicious sauce and not overly cheesy or doughy. Johnny's delivers on that. I can eat 5 slices and not feel stuffed. The pizza is not greasy or heavy. It's just the way I ate it when I was a child growing up in New York. Other competing pizza establishments use too much salt or sugar in the dough and sauce and their cheese is tasteless. Never disappointed at Johnny's. By the way, I order it with extra sauce and eat it there. I don't really eat anything else there so I cannot comment. Staffpersons are not gushy with fake smiles and overdone thank yous. They focus on preparing their food and preparing it right.
-
December 2022 by seth ye (ye.)
The staff was friendly, my cheese pizza was finished quickly and tasted amazing, and the mozzarella sticks were great. Furthermore, they had ginger ale. 10/10
-
December 2022 by Mort C.
Here's a quick review of a childhood favorite of mine! I grew up in West Orange, NJ, and unfortunate circumstances brought me back into town. Johnny's Pizzeria was old haunt us kids used to frequent waaaaay way back in our youth! As I was leaving town, I happened to drive by the location, and to my surprise, Johnny's was still open! I had to stop in and grab a slice. After more than 30 years, they are still feeding the masses, and the pizza was still very solid! They get huge points for nostalgic value.... The restaurant isn't anything fancy, but if you are passing through WO, you have to stop in for a slice and a taste of pizzeria history!! Cheers to all!!!
-
November 2022 by L55566 Sims
Great food fast and friendly service. Amazing selection of specialty sandwiches..try the Marilyn Monroe. Also Thursday is buy one get one half off on subs.
