Heritage's Dairy Stores is praised for its consistently fresh and high-quality sandwiches and ice cream. Customers prefer their hoagies over larger chains like Wawa, noting that Heritage uses fresh, sliced deli meats and bread, with toppings prepared daily. The sandwiches are described as delicious and made with real ingredients, including real eggs in breakfast options and authentic ice cream that is heavy and flavorful. Unlike some other places, Heritage's maintains the same or better quality over time, offering fresh ingredients and great service. The store is also appreciated for its quick service and friendly staff, making it a favorite spot for breakfast, lunch, or a treat. Overall, Heritage's Dairy Stores is known for its great food, real ingredients, and reliable quality.