-
December 2023 by Steven Pizzollo
I had to do this to them, but unfortunately they deserve it. I asked them before Thanksgiving if I could get center cut filet mignon. No problem, we have prime aged meats, you won't be disappointed. I told them more than once, I don't want any rubbery marbleization running through them. They looked at me like, what are you kidding, we don't sell meat like that. I placed the order and I picked it up the day before Thanksgiving. Low and behold, I unwrap it on Thanksgiving and it's exactly what I told them that I didn't want. Not only that one of the steaks was almost brown and you could see from the shape of it, it was the tail end of the filet. In addition all of the steaks were riddled with those thick rubber band marblizations. In closing, they lied about me getting center cut steaks and I could've done better at a super market, much better. I'll never go back there, and it was my first and last. Make sure you check out what they sell you. I'm going to add a photo of what I cut out the steaks before I cooked them.
-
November 2023 by Mary-Lee C.
Emilio has been our "go to" butcher for decades and every occasion is marked by the most delicious meat. His dedication to giving the highest quality of meat and more to his customers is admirable!
-
August 2023 by Sue
Best hamburger meat ever! Buy twice what you think you can eat.Freeze what you don't use. Soooo goood!Ps also the best meatloaf!
-
June 2023 by Andrew Popik
New to town and started looking for resources. Found Wyckoff Prime and have no need for anyplace else. First purchase a Prime Brisket for smoking. It was fantastic. Second purchase was a pair of Prime dry aged bone in Shells. Again, fantastic. Grabbed some of their premade meatballs and garlic bread just for kicks tonight, and again, first class provisions. Nice and helpful counter people with real knowledge. Stop in, its much more than a Butcher shop, though it is excellent at that.
-
September 2022 by Owen Corso
Locally owned butcher shop with delicious fresh, wet&dry aged steaks.
-
September 2022 by Tim K.
Step into another decade, this shop has everything you could want on demand and more if you call in advance. I walked in to check the place out a couple of months ago and asked if they had brisket, that I wanted to make a pastrami - he asked if I wanted the flat or the point, and we wanted fatty so went for the point. He took a full packer brisket and broke it down on the spot, took a ton of fat off, left the good stuff on. Today I went by to buy some ribs and ground pork for dumplings. He had both. Baby backs were thick and meaty. They also sell St. Louis style if you call them ahead of time. Next time I want to pick up some dry aged steaks. This place is heaven for a BBQ or grilling enthusiast like myself. It's worth going out of your way!
-
July 2022 by Norma S.
Went there for the first time Friday afternoon and very very impressed with the large selection of day aged meats and are cut to order. He brought out the primal cut and cut 2 rib steaks to order. Ground beef is ground to order and the burgers were the best i have ever had...melt in your mouth. I asked for some marrow bones for my dogs and even cut those (my dogs were elated.) While we were leaving the men were making fresh meatball and sausage that look fabulous. Heading back next week for more goodies
-
February 2022 by Wendy WWilliams
Awesome dry aged steaks & THE BEST GARLIC BREAD! Super helpful & nice staff!
-
July 2021 by Tom Gobuzas
Just got some meats. They have everything fresh. Forget Shoprite and Stop & Shop, do yourselves a solid and go to Wyckoff Prime Meats.
-
July 2021 by Sang S.
Great place with superior quality meats! Better than getting meats at your big box supermarkets!
-
June 2021 by Michael Hamburg
Emilio is extremely helpful and knowledgeable. I had so many questions and he answered all of them. I placed my order the day before and at 9am my ribs were ready to be picked up. Looking forward to becoming a regular here. Can’t recommend enough.
-
June 2021 by Paul Sturtevant
QualityPersonable
-
May 2021 by Nick C.
This place is amazing. They have quite a large selection of dry-aged meats that are cut-to-order, so make sure to ask what's available! My family and I got a dry-aged T-bone steak here cut to 1.5" thick, and it was one of the best steaks we've ever had (and definitely the best we ever cooked at home). The finished steak melted in our mouths like butter--the aging, thick fat cap, and great marbling made a perfect combo. We also got some meatballs from here, which were delicious. The prices here are also very reasonable. Looking forward to be back!
-
April 2021 by Lauren Troia
I stopped in to purchase something easy for dinner this week and bought burgers. They were so tasty and fresh! I found myself stopping there the following day and got breaded chicken cutlets (tasted homemade) and lamb burgers. The lamb burgers were amazing and perfectly seasoned. I am happy they are down the street from me!
-
November 2020 by Patrick Ryan
Awesome service. They have never steered me wrong.
