-
March 2024 by Rachel Angelica
My new favorite spot… they’re so friendly, the food is great! I travel for work and usually stop at fast food restaurants but I will now only come here when I’m in town for work to support this restaurant. ♥️
-
February 2024 by Brian Van Duyne
Passing though toen needed gas and spotted The Old Mill Restaurant. Nice little find Mexican menu, but burgers too. If your passing through, make a pit stop.
-
December 2023 by Angela Green
They are never open. Their posted hours mean nothing. We live across the street and haven't been able to eat here in 2 years.
-
December 2023 by Sarah W
Delicious food - I had the burger with fries smothered with red and green. The meal stayed hot and the fries crispy. Nice local atmosphere. And you can stock up on good local pinto beans - sold in bags from 2 to 50 pounds.
-
December 2023 by Todd Brogowski
The food here is consistently overly greasy to the point of being a bit nauseating. I don’t understand it because it’s all Sysco frozen foods. I can’t come here anymore given how I always feel sick afterwards.
-
December 2023 by kula join z
so welcoming. the people here are so kind. the food is amazing would definitely recommend!
-
November 2023 by NMDecalPlug
Great place to stop and get a good quality meal! It was my first time in here and I absolutely loved it.Great food, great service, and great price!
-
November 2023 by Edwina Hewett
In the past this was my go to place for eating out - I support local as much as possible. I have frequented this place since it was first opened by the Lutrick family. Today has changed that positioning for me. The food quality was pure garbage, unable to eat their burrito or burger - it was so bad my dogs (that eat anything) wouldn't touch it. Not sure where they are sourcing their ingredients but what we got there today was pure garbage. Unless they up their quality game I would NOT recommend eating any beef offerings from this place and would be highly suspect of other ingredients being used. To think - in the heart of NM surrounded by grass fed cattle this place uses what must be the cheapest most questionable beef knock off available. What a shame the Old Mill used to be quality food and service. I am waiting for a call back from the owners to ask for a refund - with or without a refund my review stands.Update -the "supervisor" Miranda called back - I told her I wanted to talk to Marth the owner/owners wife and left a message for Martha. I expressed to Miranda what this post says, she countered with they are still a busy place etc. - I told her that was great but that I still wanted to talk to Martha and that I was putting this review up. I also ask for a refund and told her with or without refund my review would stand. She hung up on me. Will see if Martha calls me back. I DO NOT RECOMMEND THIS PLACE - SAVE YOUR MONEY.
-
October 2023 by Glenda Acevedo
You're in a hurry to get your food this is not a place for you, but their food is definitely worth waiting for!
-
October 2023 by Grant Schaffer
Service is nice and the food is really good the carne adovada plate was really tasty and just
-
September 2023 by Mis Anthropy
Contact changes in times of being open and the hours of operation online never match their actual hours. The staff is also extremely rude. I used to love this place but it's gone down hill.
-
August 2023 by David Reedy
Great and helpful staff. The food was delicious. The buckaroos favorite was a tasty filling dish and the chips and salsa were stellar.
-
August 2023 by Debra Ludwig
We each had a burger, and although tasty enough almost overdone for me and my fries were a little disappointing - kind of limp for me.
-
July 2023 by Angela Green
Their hours aren't right. I'm actually not sure they're open at all. I asked on Facebook what their hours were two weeks ago (the ones posted here are incorrect) and there was no answer. We used to eat here once a week until their hours became so erratic that we couldn't figure out when they were open at all. It's really sad, because it used to be a great restaurant. But if you're never open, or you say you're open until 7 but close before 5, how can people plan to eat here??
-
July 2023 by Kelly Tabet
The food is really good worth the trip to Estancia to eat at the old mill when I go to Estancia I always eat at the old mill
