Jewelry Stores in Mesilla, NM

“Ranger the white and red shop dog is just the sweetest! I walk by his shop a couple of times a week, as part of my weekly routine. Today, I sat down on the bench outside the door, taking a break from carrying some heavy stuff in the heat, and taking a brief opportunity to enjoy the music being played at Vintage across the street. Ranger came right out to politely check on me and see whether some doggie smooches would help. (They did :-) Ranger kept me company until I was back on my feet. The humans at this shop are also pretty great (hi, humans!) but today it's all about Ranger.”

“We were in yesterday, January 2, 2026...
It was our 55th wedding anniversary and my husband decided to take me there for a gift - we've window shopped there before and they have some of the most unique jewelry. COOPER was there to help us and we can't thank her enough!! She's not only professional, but added some fun to our experience - she's NOT pushy, just helpful...Can't say enough good things about her and our experience. Thank You!!”

“Was in town for a wedding. Had some time to spare. I am a Big Jewelry person. OH MY was this shop ABSOLUTELY AMAZING. Such nice stuff. I bought a ring and a pair of earrings. Wore ring the day after I bought it and already have got compliments. Prices are reasonable. And jewelry is so beautiful. So much to see and hard to chose just one thing. LOL. LOL.”

“Huge shop with so many items to choose from, including local handcrafted items. There was so much to look at and choose from. Employees were very friendly and helpful.”

“Amazing, her staff new exactly what I wanted and...Holy cow my wife is going to love it. Both ladies are super friendly and as promised I will go tomorrow and pick out something else for my wife. If she doesn't have it in store, she will custom make. Wish I knew back when I got married 15 yes ago I would have traveled across the US just to buy from this shop...definitely worth the visit”

“My husband I are originally from El Paso but were visiting Old Mesilla on a Thursday morning from Arlington, TX. We stumbled upon Starah's store in search of the perfect wedding rings after 3 years of not having one! We meet the owner herself, Starah and she listens to our story, we have great conversations and then she directs us to the Dry Creek (sacred buffalo) white turquoise ring with sterling silver plating for me which is SO beautiful and rare as we will soon find out. My ring came with a matching necklace that I HAD to bring home with me as well. My husband bought a sterling silver band with a bear claw and a small sleeping beauty turquoise stone which she explained meant "reflection" in Native American culture which was significant to us. We left the store and took our rings to a local silversmith in El Paso who helped resize and engrave our rings in time for us to have and leave back to Arlington by Saturday morning. The silversmith was excited to see that we had legitimate sterling silver rather than nickel plated silver and reassured us by the engravings on the back of the plate. He told us about sleeping beauty stone and the rarity of dry creek white turquoise and that our stones were absolutely beautiful! This was reassuring that our interaction and transaction was genuine with Starah whom we loved her bubbly personality from the get go. THANK YOU SO MUCH STAR! <3”