-
March 2024 by Guy Madsen
Hit and miss. The pan pizza is good, the Chicago deep dish is bad. Not sure how this is the best pizza in New Mexico when it's no inconsistent.
-
March 2024 by Greg Hinze
It was
-
February 2024 by zack coe
The crusty crab pizza
-
February 2024 by Ryan Whitehead
Great calmness and they just added churros to the menu
-
February 2024 by Larissa Barreras
owner harasses customers and has employees harrass as well when they get a bad review, very rude and unprofessional
-
February 2024 by Shannon Sullivan
I don't go here anymore due to the owner blasting their customers when they don't leave good reviews. then has her employees and friends harass you. very unprofessional
-
February 2024 by Jeremy Goble
Pizza is not good. Think frozen pizza from Wal-Mart, but you also have to pay more and deal with the owner glaring at you from the back because you asked for an extra side of blue cheese dressing. At least the girl at the register was friendly.
-
February 2024 by Roger Bender
Had the Chicago Beef Calzone. EXCELLENTParking: Plenty of itKid-friendliness: Nice atmosphere for kidsWheelchair accessibility: Lots of room
-
January 2024 by Nic
Phone was answered by very professional and kind lady ( sorry I didn’t memorize her name). She knew the menu extremely well, was not rude when I needed to be corrected on the size of a specialty pizza because I did not read on the size it comes in.Husband picked up three pizzas, a full garden salad with added ham, and the cinnamon nuggets.Atmosphere was very laid back inside and the same courtesy and professionalism was still shown in person as it was on the phone.‘The Dexter’ , ‘ The Pinto’ , and cheese pizza all were delicious. Very simple pizzas with delicious flavor and of course the ‘butter crust’ just adds to the flavor.Salad was very fresh and I like how the condiments come separate in the bag.The dessert of course , just can’t go wrong with just the right amount of cinnamon and frosting ( see photo).Highly recommend this local business due to their professionalism , kind, honest friendly staff, and great options of food to choose from with very fair pricing.
-
January 2024 by Angelica Ortiz
This place was amazing fast service clean spot to stop! I lost my id while here and worker found it outside in the parking lot it was returned to me! The pizza here is amazing ? frist time here and I will be returning for more delicious food!!!Parking: Lots of safe parking right at front doorKid-friendliness: Kid safe place clean quiet alcohol free (for now)
-
January 2024 by Madelyn Hussman
Ordered the wings and beef calzone for delivery- super duper good stuff. Didn’t know what to expect for the calzone, but it was dope- get the ranch AND au jus. More than enough food for 2 adults. Quick delivery on NYE too!
-
December 2023 by Roberta Cunningham
Loved the pizza!
-
November 2023 by Christian Smithers
*** NOTE: This review is a cumulation of four years of trying to eat here and the responder from this establishment shows the level of experience I received.***I have eaten here twice so waited until I was out of the hospital to report.The first time was during a weekday and I had their pizza bowl. If you’ve ever had a desire for heartburn and indigestion undercooked in a cup, this is your meal! The acidity of the tomato paste that they used almost scorched the cheese into curds while the gooey clump of toppings made for a mixed meat ball of doom. When I asked the staff if they could remake it I was told that “take it or leave it, bro.” As I attempted to choke it down, I was accosted and forced to move to make room for some roaming band of customers from the weed shop next door.Trying to support small business, I went back again this last week to attempt to rectify my experience at Buttercrust. After seeing the flood of advertising on Facebook and the East Mountain 411 commenters on how spectacular the pizza was, I decided that was my best bet. I ordered a beer and pizza, took my number and found a seat. 20 minutes later the staff came to me and asked me to leave for loitering! Mind you, they still hadn’t delivered my beer. It and the pizza came out after a 40 minute wait. To my surprise, the beer was hot and the pizza was cold. Once again I felt the sting of the acidic canned tomato sauce burn anew, which was only tempered by the “buttered crust.” It took six napkins to wipe enough grease off to eat a slice. I saved the grease for my trailer hitch outside. After two slices, I sipped my beer just to find out not only was it coffee warm but flatter than NM41 south of town. Knowing my interactions with the high school matured staff and not wanting to interrupt their TikTok video, I knew the answer for asking to speak to the manager. I hung my head lowly knowing that I had done my best to support a local business only to be beaten by poor food and lackluster staff. Least there’s another local pizza place nearby…Sidebar: the greased up pizza slice gave me a gastrointestinal nightmare which dehydrated me to the point of hospitalization.Parking: Just park away from the weed shop, there’s plenty of room
-
November 2023 by Tabitha Chavez
Sarah is always on point with buttercrust !! Thanks for taking care of my love, you
-
November 2023 by James Reader
Excellent pizza option in the East mountains. Try the Chicago deep dish!
