Jewelry Stores near Amityville, NY

30 locations found near Amityville

“I came in with my Son son who is looking for an engagement ring. Maui and his staff took the time to explain to my Son the types of diamonds and look a like diamonds and the pros and cons of each. The staff were very patient with a young man looking to take a big step in his life. They didn't try to push him just to make a sale. Maui is very patient and kind with all of his customers. My Son said it was a very comforting experience compared to other shops . He was very impressed with the knowledge and patients of Maui and his staff. I would definitely recommend Snug Harbor Jewlers for purchases as well as repairs.”

4.9 Superb72 Reviews

“We had a rough start but I gave them a chance and they more then made up for it. Great company to do business with.We have been doing business with them for over a Year now and its been great, customer support has been superb and I want to thank Maggie for all she's done for us, She has gone to a step and above to help us even when she was sick at home .. never let us down.. Thank you again Guys”

3.8 Good13 Reviews

“Larry and his staff are always friendly, honest and incredibly helpful. My aunt recently wanted to sell some gold jewelry and after visiting several other jewelry stores that offered her much lower prices, I told her to bring to Great American Jewelers , Larry gave her a fair price and treated her with honesty and respect instead of taking advantage. It absolutely made her day!
It's so refreshing to find a business you can truly trust. I have been a customer for years and highly recommend for jewelry and LOVE their Brighton collection !”

5 Superb237 Reviews

“Beautiful, high quality jewelry. Service is impeccable—Manny is knowledgeable, friendly, and super honest. Reset my engagement stone into a stunning halo setting and created a matching eternity band. Both pieces are exquisite. Can’t recommend Maddy Fine Jewelry enough. I won’t go anywhere else.”

5 Superb187 Reviews

“Kay’s is the best great quality beautiful jewelry and Katherine was amazing she helped me find everything I needed and packed up the necklaces perfectly friendly service highly recommended store and staff”

5 Superb164 Reviews

“Mike did it again! I decided to upgrade my ring and, of course, went straight back to Mike at Elegant Jewelers. He is incredibly trustworthy, works quickly, and truly listens to what you want. Once again, he delivered the most perfect ring — exactly what I envisioned. I couldn’t be happier with the experience or the result. Highly recommend!”

5 Superb145 Reviews

“Gennaro Jewelers is the only place to go if you are looking for anything from engagement rings to earrings to necklaces and anything in between. This weekend Angela assisted my husband and I in finding exactly what we were looking for!!!

UPDATE- I was back at Gennaro last weekend and Donna was very helpful. She understood exactly what I was looking for, how much I wanted to spent, and could not have done a better job assisting me to find the perfect ring.”

5 Superb265 Reviews

“My friend bought a beautiful custom made necklace. The quality was fantastic. Everyone who worked here was so helpful and kind. Please come here for any of your jewelery needs! It's a lifetime piece my friend just purchased!”

5 Superb194 Reviews

“I have had the best experiences at Good old Gold. They helped me choose the correct setting g for my diamond earrings and the earrings look fabulous. I have also purchased a bracelet with diamonds and a beautiful necklace. The staff is amazing and so helpful with different ideas. They are courteous and I feel honest prices. Hope to be back soon!”

4.9 Superb257 Reviews

“I needed a fix for a chain for my wife. Seeing as it was my first time in a private jewelry store I didn’t know what to except. I was greeted warmly by Mike and right away he showed his expertise by easily untangling the wild chain. He told me what I was working with and showed my a subtable chain replacement that was better that what I had and matched the custom lockett I came in with. I’m happy with my purchase that didn’t break my wallet. Thank you for being the only jewelry store in the area that was open after 6. I will be back for future purchases and asking for Mike. 🙏🏾”

5 Superb172 Reviews

“I had such a great experience selling my gold here. Dalia, the owner, was incredibly caring, honest, and most importantly FAIR. She took the time to explain everything, made me feel comfortable throughout the process, and offered a price that truly felt fair compared to other places. You can tell she genuinely cares about her customers and runs her business with integrity. I highly recommend coming here if you’re looking for someone trustworthy and professional.”

5 Superb101 Reviews

“Finding an honest jeweler is rare these days, which is why my experience with Eddie was so refreshing. I initially visited to obtain an appraisal report for my insurance coverage. Before proceeding, Eddie took the time to honestly explain the true retail value of my diamond. Rather than encouraging me to pay for an appraisal I might not need, he was transparent and upfront about the situation.

Because of his integrity and professionalism, I decided to move forward with the appraisal anyway. Not only was the service exceptional, but their appraisal fee was approximately 70–75% lower than what I was quoted in New York City and the surrounding counties. In fact, Eddie even charged me less than the standard appraisal fee.

The drive was absolutely worth it. It's rare to find a business that genuinely prioritizes honesty, customer satisfaction, and the best interests of its clients over making a quick sale.

Thank you, Eddie, for your outstanding service. I look forward to seeing you again soon to discuss the watch we talked about.”

5 Superb120 Reviews

“Nuha rocks. Honestly I didnt think I would get the ring made before the time frame i was given. They listen to every little detail, they make sure you feel good about whatever purchase your about to make. Thank you so much. You guys definitely essed my nerves lol. I will definitely send more people your way.”

4.9 Superb199 Reviews

“Took my grandmother's ring to get cleaned up and dipped in white gold for an engagement, came out absolutely beautiful. Then had to have that same ring repaired and now it's stronger than before!”

5 Superb99 Reviews

“The best place in town for all types of jewelry and watches! Professional and reliable! Very reasonably priced and knows his work!
Always a pleasure working with them.”

4.9 Superb169 Reviews

“Matthew is a very well educated and highly certified professional with a passion for gemology. He has a professional lab in his office with up to 30 instruments at his disposal. I came in with a couple of fairly rare stones and he did a very thorough analysis. He researched them, spending probably more time than it was worth for him to come up with a reliable current retail value. His rate was very reasonable to boot. He was very personable even though it was late in the day which made it a fun visit as well. He will definitely be my ‘go to guy’ for any future appraisals.”

5 Superb75 Reviews

“Stan is truly the best jeweler on Long Island. My family has been going to him for years, and we’ve always been impressed by his knowledge, professionalism, and exceptional service. We recommend him to everyone we know and wouldn’t trust anyone else!”

4.9 Superb145 Reviews

“I’ve been coming to Levit Jewelers for years for gifts, repairs, and appraisals and they have always been wonderful. Recently, I brought in several pieces of my mother’s jewelry that she left to me. Many of them were broken, with cracked stones and dulled settings, and I wasn’t sure how much could be restored.
When I picked them up, I was truly moved. Every piece had been beautifully repaired and brought back to life and absolutely stunning. The care and craftsmanship that went into restoring something so meaningful to me was incredible. The cost was also affordable. I’m beyond grateful and will continue to be a loyal customer for years to come.”

5 Superb87 Reviews

“Al was an amazing help. I wish I got more on my laptop, but he told me why it wasn’t going to be more, and it overall makes sense. I will be coming back for sure.”

4.8 Superb173 Reviews

“Always a great experience at this Deer park location. And to make your experience even better ask for Mariana V. The absolute best and she will treat you like family. We purchased my wife's engagement ring from her. With Mariana's experience and guidance, my wife absolutely love her ring. Thank you Mariana.”

4.8 Superb150 Reviews

“My husband and I have both have had great experiences at Rontal. He bought me a beautiful sapphire and diamond bracelet this past Christmas. I bought my daughter a beautiful circle diamond necklace for her graduation.
This week I went in to have my diamond replaced in my engagement ring. It had fallen out😭, I was able to find it 😊, and Ben replaced it, shined everything up, 🤩 !!
I can’t wait to go back with some of my/my mother’s pieces to have them make me something special. I follow them on instagram and LOVE all the transformations! My sister had a piece made and it is stunning! 😍 —Anastasia S.”

4.9 Superb121 Reviews

“Lifelong jeweler since I can remember and it never disappoints! Manny always takes the time to help us pick out the perfect piece and offers great prices afterwards. Would highly recommend.”

4.9 Superb101 Reviews

“I’ve used Zicana multiple times over a span of 25 years and every project they’ve completed has exceeded my expectations every time! Frank and his team are the absolute best and such a pleasure to work with. Highly Recommend 10/10”

4.8 Superb193 Reviews

“So happy I came into this establishment. Professional, caring, a huge selection of wonderful staff. I was thrilled with my purchases and this will be my go to place to buy jewelry in the future!”

4.8 Superb165 Reviews

“Amazing customer service and great collection! Worked with Raavi and she was very helpful and knowledgeable. We would always go to Jackson Heights but East West has a far better collection and pricing. Owner is very welcoming and helped with sizing a ring as well!”

4.8 Superb128 Reviews

“Jen was awesome! She was clear, calm and efficient. Super nice! The store was filling up and she was alone (kids off from school) and she kept her cool and took her time with me. Piercing was a breeze! Please get more white gold options! Will definitely be back :)”

4.7 Superb125 Reviews

“I always have a wonderful shopping experience at the store. Everything I’ve ever purchased is top-notch, and everyone who is there at the store is super helpful, incredibly nice, and very knowledgeable. Stop by, and I’m sure that you’ll find a treasure to take home with you!”

4.8 Superb76 Reviews

“It was my first time at a pawnbrokers and honestly did not know much about it but the store manager, Kevin, was so incredibly helpful and straightforward in explaining things and answering all my questions. Definitely left feeling like I learned more. Really appreciate your help, and thanks again!”

4.8 Superb116 Reviews

“I had a great experience at Collectors Jeweler. The staff was incredibly friendly, welcoming, and honest throughout the entire process. They took the time to answer all of my questions and made me feel comfortable from the moment I walked in. Their customer service was excellent. I truly appreciated their professionalism and kindness. I would definitely recommend Collectors Jeweler to anyone looking for a trustworthy and pleasant jewelry buying or selling experience.”

4.7 Superb170 Reviews

“When I was shopping for my wife’s Rolex 26MM two tone with a champagne diamond dial and custom diamond bezel, I was referred to a well known social media jeweler who promotes himself as honest and transparent. To make sure I was getting the best value and quality, I also reached out to Mark from ItsHot Diamond Jewelry & Watches.

The difference was clear.

Mark has been consistent since the first time I worked with him six years ago. He is professional, patient, and incredibly detail oriented. He takes the time to answer every question, explain everything clearly, and guide you through the process without any pressure. Most importantly, he listens and genuinely cares about getting it right.

Since this was my wife’s first Rolex, I wanted everything to be exactly how she envisioned it. Mark and his team were extremely accommodating and made sure every detail was right.

In the end, the decision was easy. We chose Mark and ItsHot Diamond Jewelry & Watches for their exceptional service, top tier quality, and the best value. The entire experience was smooth, transparent, and stress free. You are not just buying jewelry, you are working with someone who truly acts as your advisor.

On top of that, I was able to use my reward points from previous purchases to get my wife a pair of diamond earrings, which made the experience more meaningful. Being able to earn and apply points toward future pieces makes the overall experience more rewarding.

This was truly a win-win, and we are beyond satisfied. I highly recommend Mark and ItsHot Diamond Jewelry & Watches to anyone looking for quality, trust, and a great overall experience.

Thank you again, Mark. I appreciate you and your team.

Best regards,
An”

4.8 Superb112 Reviews