NoFo Pot Pies is a highly recommended dining establishment known for its delicious food, friendly service, and inviting atmosphere. Customers enjoy a variety of menu options, including seafood like broiled swordfish and potato crusted sea bass, as well as comforting dishes such as onion soup and pork chops with mashed potatoes. The desserts, including rice pudding, Key Lime pie, and coconut cream pie, are described as scrumptious and satisfying. The restaurant often features special offerings like sampler plates that showcase a mix of beef, chicken, vegetarian, and seafood options, all praised for their quality and flavor.
The ambiance is beautiful and warm, especially around the holidays, making it a delightful place to dine. Staff members are attentive, friendly, and strive to make guests feel welcomed, with some reviews highlighting exceptional service from servers who are lively and accommodating. Although a family with children once caused some disturbance, the staff handled the situation well, and customers appreciated the effort, which was often met with compensation like coffee and dessert. Overall, NoFo Pot Pies provides a wonderful dining experience characterized by great food, excellent service, and a cozy atmosphere that keeps guests returning.
Great chicken pot pies, young women at pickup window was helpful all question I had about freezing and cooking pies
August 2026
Food was good. Service wssnt great. Not allot of attention to detail. Ordered bread that was forgotten and arrived much later. Swordfowas outstanding. Stuffed clams not very good.
August 2026
Love, love, love Coleridge Inn. It never disappoints. I made my reservation the morning of & still received the table I had asked for. Great atmosphere, fantastic food & wonderful service. Thank you Liz! No matter how often you eat there, the food is always consistently good. It's definitely our happy place!
