River Bay Outfitters is a highly regarded fly fishing store located in Baldwin, Long Island. Customers appreciate its old-timey charm, knowledgeable staff, and well-stocked selection of fly fishing gear, including flies, rods, and reels. The owner, Paul, and his son, Owen, are praised for their expertise, patience, and dedication to customer service, making every visitor feel welcome regardless of their skill level. The shop offers guided trips, seminars, and casual meet-ups, providing a community atmosphere for fly fishing enthusiasts. Many customers express their intent to return, noting that River Bay Outfitters is a unique establishment and the best option for fly fishing on Long Island. Overall, it is a stellar destination for anyone looking to enhance their fly fishing experience.
Would 100% recommend this shop to anyone in the area looking for a fly shop or gear. Paul was incredibly welcoming and cordial, and provided some very helpful guidance. Will definitely be coming back!
August 2025
One word describes Paul and his establishment: OUTSTANDING. The attention to detail, knowledge, customer service and matching with the right equipment is second to none. I have had nothing short of a great experience with the shop and his trips.Paul is a wealth of knowledge when it comes to fly fishing.
June 2025
The most expertise fishing experience in Long Island . All the true fishermen come here an isntitution among serous fishermen . You will be in heaven .
