24HR Fuel Available Crosby’s is your local family-owned convenience store and gas station, proudly serving communities across NY & PA. Offering oven-fresh pizza slices, quality fuel, and more— Crosby’s has everything you need! Stop in store now or order online!
I got a half chicken parm today requesting light sauce and add onion. It was perfect!! What a great sub. Thanks Toni!!
Now today months later I just got an amazing piece of bossy chicken canzone made by Julia it was firm but not hard still crispy and loaded. Delicious!!
January 2026
Ordered fingers and pizza tonight the 8th of January. It was cooked perfect and ready when I arrived there. Always have good food when I order in the evening. The Andy and Tiff team are great.
December 2025
The employee Julie there always knows what to do. She’s always so kind to everyone coming in the store, makes you feels welcome. Remembers orders and gets them correct, and done in a timely manner. Has the store in tip top shape at all times. Great food service. Absolutely amazing. And so clean. Love love love it here.
