Auto Insurance near Bay Shore, NY

29 locations found near Bay Shore
View Map

“mike is absolutely the best! he completely helped me and my mom out through the insurance process and more! he treats every client like his family and his kindness/generosity is something that is much needed in this world:) we love you mike and thank you so much!!!”

5 Superb52 Reviews

“Started using Chris about a year ago for a Homeowners policy. My experience with him has been exceptional and since then have migrated all of my other policies for business, rentals and auto over to his agency. I've never felt more confident with my coverages. Would Def recommend to others.”

5 Superb13 Reviews

“Janine, Thank you. A pleasure speaking with you. Our conversation was picture picture-perfect example of Top-notch customer service!I had a lot of tough questions, and your answers were 'on point'! Glad to have Janine Dipalma and State Farm as my insurance providers and agents.”

5 Superb50 Reviews

“Called about a year ago to obtain an estimate on insurance; was just about to start to shop around for insurance again. It was like Joe Williams read my mind. He called and emailed me to follow up after we had a conversation a few months back. This time around gave me a quote I couldn’t just not take. He was amazing! Persistent and informative. Thank you Joe for your great service !”

5 Superb39 Reviews

“Not to be cliche, but Jenn at this State Farm office has saved me more money, time, and aggravation then Jake at State Farm ever could. If you're looking to save money, get really go coverage for home, auto, life and umbrella coverage as I have, don't wait another minute and call this office, and speak to NO ONE BUT Jenn. She's exceptionally knowledgeable, professional and considerate to everyone of your insurance needs. Thank you Jenn for all your help in the past, present and future! God bless Jenn from State Farm!”

5 Superb38 Reviews

“I have been working with your LPL risk management for many years. My agent is Catherine, Reuter, she is so attentive and helpful no matter what I call about. She has helped me over the many years today I had a problem I had called and then emailed within minutes. I got a callback from one of your agents a Debbie Stark! And my issue was resolved over the phone. My issue was with Travelers insurance company. I have had many issues with them and your company has come through every time I can’t say enough about how wonderful your agents are. Thank you.Diane MurphyI do recommend them to all that I know again thank you”

5 Superb30 Reviews

“Always a pleasure to speak with Chris or Betty or Wendy. They are helpful, knowledgeable, and professional. I feel like they listen and understand what I need and provide excellent advise on how to proceed. Great team”

5 Superb25 Reviews

“State Farm coming through again!!! Literally had Liz on the phone right away while at the dealership. I was texting her all the info she needed to get my insurance sent right over. Fantastic and fast service! Always appreciated! Thanks Liz!”

4.9 Superb56 Reviews

“The Team at Colstan is absolutely incredible. They are always there when I have a question or need a document. I highly recommended them to all of our family and friends. They provide our personal policies as well as our business policies.”

4.9 Superb42 Reviews

“I just recently switched over to State Farm for all my insurance needs and the whole staff is just great ! Joe helped me with everything and was informative , professional and just all around pleasant to work with ! I would highly recommend this agency !”

5 Superb20 Reviews

“I have been with this specific agency since I began driving in 1973. The best of the best. Always so helpful with any and all situations.In 1985 bought my first house and bundled insurance getting additional discounts. Love everyone, Tara, Harold, Marie. So helpful.”

5 Superb20 Reviews

“I found Steve Conte based on reviews and have been a customer for the last few years. I recently contacted him regarding an insurance issue, and he was extremely helpful and responsive as always. It's nice dealing with someone who genuinely has your best interests in mind (not to mention that he is the most competent broker I've ever dealt with). I would highly recommend for all your insurance needs.”

4.9 Superb29 Reviews

“Mr. Angelia Santiago combined my auto and home insurance and saved me more than 900 dollars on the policy. Plus his personal attention and excellent service was exceeded my expectations. Thanks”

5 Superb7 Reviews

“The people you speak with treat you very respectfully and the utmost courtesy! They will find you a what you need at a very competitive price! I have been using them for about 7 years and I have never had a problem. I would totally recommend them!!”

4.8 Superb16 Reviews

“Honesty, dedication and compassion are hard to find nowadays. These values I found when working with Michael and his team. Thank you for giving hope to my family and for your transparency at the right time.”

5 Superb3 Reviews

“Excellent customer service! They really made the process of getting insurance smooth - and tried multiple scenarios to make sure that I was getting exactly what I needed! Thanks guys!”

5 Superb3 Reviews

“When my agent retired I was afraid my new agent wouldn’t be as responsive, helpful, friendly, and provide the best discounts available without me asking. Well I was wrong! Bruna Caravousanos goes above and beyond! She responds almost immediately, is always friendly, keeps you updated on pending claims, and even assists when the claims department doesn’t properly handle their end. She does not have to do that, yet she still does. I’m extremely happy with Bruna, she is definitely one of the reasons I stay with Allstate.”

4.7 Superb17 Reviews

“I have been with Allstate for 50 years, a fair amount of that time with Rob. I recently had a claim where my vehicle was hit and run. We had some other stuff going on too, Rob took control and made it all easy, Can't say enough great things about Rob and his staff. If you need insurance without the bovine scatology call Rob!!!”

4.7 Superb13 Reviews

“OK THATS IT I LIVE IN THAT APRTMENT AND JUST FYI ITS PRIVITE PROPERTY SO YOU EITHER STOP IT OR I CALL THE POLICE AND MY GRANDPA IS A RETIRED POLICE SO DONT TAKE PHOTOS OF MY HOUSE AGIENE OR I CALL THE POLICE NOW TELL ME WHO ARE YOU!?”

4.7 Superb6 Reviews

“I've been using this office for a longgg time with my whole family. Great people and they're always there to help. Keep it up guys and thanks for everything!”

4.6 Superb10 Reviews

“Steve Grosse is the best. I shopped to every insurance company out there. No one has come close. And when I shop it now the other companies are shocked at the coverage and price I have.”

4.5 Superb22 Reviews

“This company is spectacular. They were able to save me almost 1/3 of my current insurance payments and help a young driver to be able to lease a brand new car affordably. Make sure to ask for agent John Visgauss for even more help, he clearly knows his profession and will be able to help and save you a fortune.”

4.1 Good9 Reviews

“I would like to say thank you to Janet Nicole Carol at Allstate they are always ready to help in anyway they can if you want people that are always there for you and really have your best interests at heart they are the people to call”

4 Good8 Reviews

“My mother and I have been using this team for years (even before they moved to their current Greenlawn location). Maria is wonderful and will always be able to provide answers to your questions (and if she doesn’t know the answer off-hand, she will do her research and find the answers for you promptly!) Can’t say enough good things about Joseph and his team! Thank you for guys for always providing excellent customer service and product information!”

4.3 Superb32 Reviews

“I got a call from Vanderbeck agency offering me to move to Allstate. They took care of most things over the phone and gave me a better deal for my home and car. I do recommend them.”

4.2 Good48 Reviews

“Bob McMahon and State Farm car insurance has been great for many years in our household.Recently, we needed help ‘ASAP’ and Mr. McMahon came through. So appreciated....Thank you much!!!!!”

3.3 Good7 Reviews

“Good work by agent, Kristen Seubert, for volunteering information regarding NY State mandated 10% discount on insurance with completion of Defensive Driving Course.”

4 Good39 Reviews

“I love working with this office! I’ve used Allstate and Progressive in the past but the customer service and policies in comparison are unmatched. The agent that helped me was incredibly attentive and informative and the rest of the staff was very welcoming and helpful. I went for a quote and decided to switch right then, I couldn’t have asked for better agents.”

3.5 Good16 Reviews