Gift Shops near Bay Shore, NY

15 locations found near Bay Shore

“Best place to buy a gift. The staff is friendly and they gift wrap. They have many unique gift choices. Christine delivered great customer service. I would give more than 5 stars if Google let me.”

4.7 Superb94 Reviews

“Great place to shop for last minute gifts. I love the bracelet they carry. The ladies that work there are always helpful and go out of their way to gift wrap for you.”

4.5 Superb34 Reviews

“This is a small local gift shop that has everything and anything you can possibly think of for gifting someone. The have a wide selection of jewelry, figurines, toys, frames, house wares, trinkets, and more. The staff is friendly and helpful. They also sell helium balloons for all occasions.

I will highlight that this shop has a large turnover of the items they sell; meaning that every time I visit I find new things on the shelves. The store is small, but it is packed with nicely selected items that are a pleasure to look at and buy.

They also offer a large selection of cards for all occasions. They have gifts for special occasions such as weddings, baptisms, first communions and more.

Forget Amazon, instead go to this local store to buy a special gift that will for sure be a hit.”

4.7 Superb35 Reviews

“I can’t say enough good things about them. I have used them multiple times their service is always fast and kind. This week as they transition to a new store owner and their systems were down. I came in for a last-minute purchase. They were quick to help me. They were not able to get the system back up In a timely manner that they offered to cover my purchase. To me that speaks Remarkable customer service!! I will definitely be returning and keep using them!!”

4.2 Good61 Reviews

“5 star nice ppl nice store. THAT said I will not return. Large women with brittle blond hair is rude. . For no reason other than it's who she is . I spend 150 a week there an will go elsewhere. A person can be many things so why not be kind.”

4.6 Superb13 Reviews

“ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!!! I dealt with Alex from Lake Grove and he was incredible. So helpful and very sincerely involved with the customization and making sure you are happy with your choice. He helped me choose the right size crystal and made some adjustments to make sure it looked perfect. This was a birthday gift for my mom and he was determined to make sure it was great!! He made the 3D look amazing when I was nervous about the photo and was very passionate about what he was doing. Amazing service and so quick, only 3 days max!! Highly recommend and will definitely visit again!!”

4.6 Superb20 Reviews

“This very quaint store has many gift items like; candles, cards, cups, costume jewelry, stuffed toys, childrens books, Hallmark itmes and cards. It is well designed and it has a nice Mom and Pop vibe.”

4.4 Superb33 Reviews

“Amazing service!!! Wow!! I didn’t catch the ladies name who assisted me but, she was awesome. Last minute order, just 2 hours before closing she was able to make it happen!! Thank you so much for that and the delivery was super fast!”

4 Good84 Reviews

“I visited On a Whim for the first time today. It was filled with a variety of collections for special events like weddings, babies, communions, new home, among other fun stuff like jewelry candles, kitchen , and various items. The person working helped me find the perfect sign to purchase for a house warming gift after I told her what I was there for. She was very kind. I will definitely be back again.”

5 Superb16 Reviews

“Klines is hands down the best shop in Ocean Beach. I have been spending my summers on the island for over a decade and never miss a chance to shop here. They have quality Fire Island clothing and the owner, Matt, is an awesome guy. I also take my young nephews to Klines and they love picking out clothes and toys in the kids section, I really appreciate how kind the kids are always treated by Matt and the staff. Definitely recommend you check this place out if you're in town.”

5 Superb8 Reviews

“I recently ordered from Edible Arrangements for a friend's birthday, and I was genuinely impressed. The fruit was super fresh — like, you could actually taste the difference — and the arrangement looked exactly like the picture online (which never happens). Delivery was smooth too; it arrived right on time with everything still cold and crisp.

The only thing I'd say is that it’s definitely a bit pricey for the size, but honestly, you’re paying for the presentation and the quality, and in this case, it felt worth it. My friend absolutely loved it, and it made the gift feel a lot more special than just sending flowers or chocolates. Would definitely order again for a special occasion.”

3.9 Good94 Reviews

“I have been to this location multiple times and would definitely recommended!! The customer service is always amazing. The staff are very friendly and go above and beyond when helping me through the process of picking an arrangement. The arrangements are always beautifully made and the fruits they use are fresh!”

3.9 Good64 Reviews

“Great service! Had to put a plush animal toy on hold for a few days for a pick up. Item was confirmed and placed on hold. Picked it up last evening. My Mom is obsessed with her gift!”

3.9 Good44 Reviews

“Sooner or later people are going to realize you can't just order everything online you need to touch feel smell and see what a great tragedy it will be if we lose all of our walls I love coming here when I can it's always clean they always have what you need and what you want I hope and pray you never leave thanks for always being there.”

3.8 Good65 Reviews

“Very pleased. I placed an order as a gift that was either stolen or delivered to the wrong address, which is not the stores fault. I spoke with Ahmad (I hope I spelled this right) and he was extremely personable and accommodating. He was willing to make things right immediately by delivering the same arrangement again at no charge. This is a location you can trust. Thank you for the amazing customer service! Will def shop here again!”

1.8 Poor72 Reviews

Related Categories