Home Insurance near Bay Shore, NY

26 locations found near Bay Shore

“Thank you....Thank You ...Nellie I just wanted to write a quick note To let you know how appreciative I was for fixing something in minutes that I thought would take a week or more I appreciated it more than you could know... Michael S Stagnitta State Farm has a staff like no other! I have never been treated this well with other Insurance company like this in 30 years...
Teresa Pagnani ❤️ A+”

5 Superb82 Reviews

“Started using Chris about a year ago for a Homeowners policy. My experience with him has been exceptional and since then have migrated all of my other policies for business, rentals and auto over to his agency. I've never felt more confident with my coverages. Would Def recommend to others.”

4.8 Superb32 Reviews

“This group is the best. They are responsive without being overbearing. They took care of my insurance needs seamlessly and a a great price. I highly recommend them. ?
Jim Cresser”

5 Superb139 Reviews

“I have been with this agency for almost 20 years. Everyone is very professional, courteous, and goes above and beyond to meet the customers needs. Any claims we have made have been handled promptly with minimal impact to our premiums. Most recently, Roseanne
from the office Helped me do an audit and reduce our vehicle premiums. We really appreciate her going above and beyond and the professionalism of this office.”

5 Superb80 Reviews

“I have been with State Farm FOREVER (46 years), and the folks at the Simone agency have always been super helpful. Whether it’s for insurance, notary, or just helping me get my ducks in a row for the DMV, these folks have always been stellar. Thanks everyone!!”

5 Superb62 Reviews

“Peggy is an exceptional insurance agent, and I couldn't be happier with the service I received. She was instrumental in helping me secure a fantastic home insurance policy, ensuring that I had all the correct coverages without any pressure to upsell.

Beyond the home policy, she also took the time to review my auto insurance, offering expert guidance to make sure those coverages were perfectly aligned with my needs. What I appreciated most was her approach: she was incredibly patient, answering all my numerous questions thoroughly, and was never pushy. It truly felt like she had my best interest at heart. If you're looking for an honest, knowledgeable, and patient insurance professional, Peggy is the one to call!”

4.9 Superb107 Reviews

“LPL has helped many of our clients get the right level of coverage for their businesses at competitive rates, and more importantly, whenever there’s a problem or question that comes up they are so on top of it, they truly become a key partner to the business owners because of the high level of service.”

5 Superb42 Reviews

“Janine DiPalma and her team (Danielle and Andrew & All) are the very best example of excellence possible- if there were 10 more rating stars - Janine would get them ALL! I’m so happy & proud to be a client.
Professional, friendly and very informed about the industry, market conditions and experts in Long Island insurance is what you expect from the best and they deliver all of that - every time. What sets Janine apart from other agencies is the level of passion for what she does and how she views service from a human perspective. Janine follows up - covers all the bases and does ALL the heavy lifting so you don’t have to.
The team is all consistently on the same page so there is always the same response no matter who you are speaking with - they are honest and fair and willing to spend the time to not only answer questions but ensure their response is understood. Janine and State Farm REALLY is there! Thank you as your are greatly appreciated!!”

4.9 Superb74 Reviews

“Gilberto Barahona, was excellent to deal with in getting insurance for my son. He followed up and explain everything so I could understand it while saving my son money…”

4.9 Superb66 Reviews

“The Team at Colstan is absolutely incredible. They are always there when I have a question or need a document. I highly recommended them to all of our family and friends. They provide our personal policies as well as our business policies.”

4.9 Superb66 Reviews

“Dennis Scannell and his State Farm team are great. They have competitive rates and top-notch service! They are always available to help and I highly recommend them!!!!!”

5 Superb37 Reviews

“I have been with this specific agency since I began driving in 1973. The best of the best. Always so helpful with any and all situations.In 1985 bought my first house and bundled insurance getting additional discounts. Love everyone, Tara, Harold, Marie. So helpful.”

5 Superb19 Reviews

“Great service from these guys. I called to just get some info but they really went above and beyond by getting me a quick answer. And the price I got was where I wanted to be. Happy I found this place.”

5 Superb16 Reviews

“Steve is available to answer my questions in a timely manner, from the details of the policy to my general questions about insurance. He helped me find additional bundle savings across my home and auto. Overall, good value for the products and services offered.”

4.9 Superb23 Reviews

“I had a great experience working with Jessica Birsner at office ! She took the time to compare options and helped me save a significant amount on my auto insurance. Super knowledgeable, patient, and transparent. Highly recommend her to anyone looking to save money and get honest advice!”

4.8 Superb69 Reviews

“I have been with Allstate for 50 years, a fair amount of that time with Rob. I recently had a claim where my vehicle was hit and run. We had some other stuff going on too, Rob took control and made it all easy, Can't say enough great things about Rob and his staff. If you need insurance without the bovine scatology call Rob!!!”

5 Superb15 Reviews

“This company is spectacular. They were able to save me almost 1/3 of my current insurance payments and help a young driver to be able to lease a brand new car affordably. Make sure to ask for agent John Visgauss for even more help, he clearly knows his profession and will be able to help and save you a fortune.”

5 Superb12 Reviews

“I would like to say thank you to Janet Nicole Carol at Allstate they are always ready to help in anyway they can if you want people that are always there for you and really have your best interests at heart they are the people to call”

4.6 Superb19 Reviews

“OK THATS IT I LIVE IN THAT APRTMENT AND JUST FYI ITS PRIVITE PROPERTY SO YOU EITHER STOP IT OR I CALL THE POLICE AND MY GRANDPA IS A RETIRED POLICE SO DONT TAKE PHOTOS OF MY HOUSE AGIENE OR I CALL THE POLICE NOW TELL ME WHO ARE YOU!?”

4.3 Superb10 Reviews

“I was in a car accident on a Sunday a while back and I was amazed at State Farms response to my situation. I called Sunday night to report the accident and by early Monday morning my agent at the West Islip location called me, I didn't even have to call them. They immediately set me up with a Rental car by noon that same day. They were all so helpful, kind and understanding and helped me throughout the whole process. I would highly recommend State Farm for anyone undecided on where yo go for car insurance.”

4.5 Superb12 Reviews

“The people you speak with treat you very respectfully and the utmost courtesy! They will find you a what you need at a very competitive price! I have been using them for about 7 years and I have never had a problem. I would totally recommend them!!”

4.3 Superb19 Reviews

“Steve Grosse is the best. I shopped to every insurance company out there. No one has come close. And when I shop it now the other companies are shocked at the coverage and price I have.”

4.4 Superb21 Reviews

“I HAVE BEEN WITH ALLSTATE INSURANCE
COMPANY FOR MORE THAN THREE YEARS.
SO FAR IT HAS BEEN A GREAT EXPIRIENCE
THEY OFFER AUTO ,BOAT ,MOTORCYCLE
HOME N RENTAL INSURANCE ROAD SIDE ASSISTANCE, AND THEY'RE VERY ATTENT
IVE TO WHAT THEY PROVIDE AS SERVICE..
IF YOU'RE LOOKING FOR AN INSURANCE COMPANY YOU CAN RELLY ON ,I WILL RE
COMMEND ALLSTATE AND NOT BECAUSE
ITS MY COMPANY BUT BECAUSE THEY'RE
VERY PROFESSIONAL WHEN IT COMES TO TREATING THEY'RE CUSTOMERS !”

4.1 Good24 Reviews

“I’ve been using Bob for well over 15 years. Both Bob and his staff are extremely professional and personable. They always help get me the best rates with new policies, especially when adding my children to my policy. I highly recommend them to anyone looking to switch brokers.”

3.5 Good12 Reviews

“Excellent, excellent, excellent, thank you so much for making my insurance experience and change to Allstate extremely easy, answering all questions and assistance with details to my new policies and savings”

4.1 Good66 Reviews

“I've been working with this local agency of State Farm for almost 8 years and they are so efficient and knowledgeable. At the time I was a new homeowner and I worked with Bryan Perez to obtain home insurance and of course coverage for my vehicle. He was patient with me as I had so much transpiring at once and new to the process, he took his time to explain things to me and answered my questions with great ease. And, to this day (2025) he is very responsive to all my inquiries. Bryan is always a pleasure to work with and is professional, he acts quickly to get answers and always follows up. When Bryan isn't around, I've worked with Addison and Leanette who are also professional and easy to work with. Having a good relationship with your insurance agent is comforting but they also do their best to get the best rates they can for their clients which is greatly appreciated. This agency, Jennifer Rivera - State Farm Insurance Agents are bright and very helpful so I highly recommend them.”

3.4 Good33 Reviews